Who won in Marco Rubio-Patrick Murphy debate? Florida voters


Republican U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio needed a chance to show he’s done something despite missing so much time at work, and he did so.

Democratic U.S. Rep. Patrick Murphy needed a chance to show he’s more than just a rich, pretty face running for the Senate, and he did so.

And Florida voters needed a chance to hear about more than just Rubio’s commitment to Donald Trump or Murphy’s trust in Hillary Clinton, and they did so.

Monday night’s first U.S. Senate debate at the University of Central Florida, produced by Orlando TV station WFTV Channel 9 and broadcast statewide, made news as Rubio promised that — God willing — he intends to serve his six years in the Senate. And it raised eyebrows as Rubio essentially trashed Trump and Clinton as both bad, but said he’s sticking with Trump, while Murphy ignored Rubio’s characterization of Clinton as untrustworthy said he trusted her, as the two spent nearly 15 minutes talking about whose presidential candidate was worse.

But in the other 45 minutes, the rivals drew clear distinctions on where they stand on abortion, gun control, the Iran treaty, immigration reform, the Affordable Care Act, the Everglades, global warming, and Cuba. The only thing they agreed on was both expressed confidence the election would be fair, voting would be sound and trustworthy, and the results would be accepted.

“There was a much more in-depth discussion of policy than we’ve seen in any of these debates,” said University of South Florida political scientist Susan MacManus. “When it came to legislation and what was going on during their time in legislative positions, they really gave much more depth to it.”

And while Murphy tried hard and repeatedly to tie Rubio to Trump [perhaps his best prospect for knocking the senator back from his lead in the polls], it wasn’t until late in the debate that there was even a wobble to Rubio’s responses. Instead, much of the debate featured Rubio playing the experienced, conscientious politician who’s not afraid to take tough stands, even if those stands would chase away voters, while Murphy went on the attack.

Time and again Murphy accused Rubio of not showing up — of having the worst record in the Senate, and the worst for a Florida senator in 50 years — and pointed to his own 97 percent attendance record. But Rubio didn’t sound like someone who wasn’t getting anything done, ticking off bills he had sponsored into law or pushed, including Everglades restoration, human trafficking, Obamacare funding, and foreign policy. That was the charge he laid on Murphy, repeatedly challenging the two-term congressman from Palm Beach Gardens to name his top accomplishments, then belittling them.

“I think Rubio had a stronger performance, particularly for the first 40, 45 minutes. Murphy did come back stronger toward the end, particularly with the question about reproductive rights, women’s rights, overall. But I don’t know if he did enough in this first debate to change the dynamics,” said UCF political scientist Aubrey Jewett.

His Republican surrogates pointed to the same thing. Lt. Gov. Carlos Lopez-Cantera and Bertica Cabrera Morris of Orlando both argued afterwards that Rubio talked about ample accomplishments, while Murphy, in Cabrera Morris’s words, “doesn’t have any.”

But voters who watched the debate will be able to see the distinctions on the issues, and vote based on those. Even Rubio acknowledged that one issue in particular — abortion — may have him in the minority of Floridians’ views.

“And it really really showed that Marco Rubio has a record of … turning his back on Floridians when it matters the most, turning his back on immigrants in Florida, turning his back on the LGBT community after the Pulse shooting, and turning his back on women,” said Carlos Guillermo Smith, a Democrat running for Florida House Seat 49. “I think that came through loud and clear.”

The turn in Murphy’s performance came after Rubio tried to walk a fine line between saying he has great respect for a woman’s right to control her body, but he favors the rights of children to be born, even in cases of Zika infections.

“Some of these issues are very difficult issues. But I do so with the utmost respect for others who have a different point of view,” Rubio said.

 And after Rubio complained Murphy and Clinton have extreme positions on abortion — claiming they support it in any case, but get a pass in the media for such an extreme position — and then accused Murphy of posting a picture on Facebook of himself groping a woman, Murphy brought home the point he wanted: charging that Rubio has shown no support for women’s rights.

“Let’s just talk about Donald Trump again, right? Think about who my opponent, Marco Rubio, has endorsed to be our next president: bragging about sexually assaulting women?” Murphy said. “I don’t need to hear a lecture from you on women’s rights. You do not support a women’s right to chose. When asked about equal pay for women, your quote was that it is a waste of time.”

Another of Murphy’s biggest hopes — one he brought up in his opening remarks — was defused when Rubio stated he intended to serve out his full term in the U.S. Senate, if re-elected. The widely held assumption suggests he would seek another presidential run in 2020, and until now he has dodged committing to serving a full term.

“I’m going to serve in the Senate for the next six years, God willing,” Rubio said. “I am going to be senator for the next six years on behalf of the state of Florida. You can’t be senator and president at the same time.”

But that didn’t convince everyone.

“It sounded to me when he added ‘God willing,’ he was giving himself a little bit of an out there, just in case,” said retired Orlando Police Chief Val Demings, a Democrat running for Florida’s 10th Congressional District.


Scott Powers

Scott Powers is an Orlando-based political journalist with 30+ years’ experience, mostly at newspapers such as the Orlando Sentinel and the Columbus Dispatch. He covers local, state and federal politics and space news across much of Central Florida. His career earned numerous journalism awards for stories ranging from the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster to presidential elections to misplaced nuclear waste. He and his wife Connie have three grown children. Besides them, he’s into mystery and suspense books and movies, rock, blues, basketball, baseball, writing unpublished novels, and being amused. Email him at [email protected].


  • Michael Aller

    October 18, 2016 at 8:55 am

    The God willing part really stuck with me as little Marco kept repeating it. I think Marco really believes that God wants him to be President ! Scary stuff.

  • Sean

    October 18, 2016 at 5:36 pm

    Patrick Murphy is a liar and a fraud, who purposely misled voters on his resume for political gain. That, right there, should disqualify Murphy from the job he seeks.

  • Bruce K

    October 20, 2016 at 11:01 am

    As an Iindependent undecided voter, Marco Rubio clearly won this debate, but the bigger issue is Marco showed true empathy for unborn children, and the rights of these children. You have to respect that, cause at the end of the day, isn’t that important? Rubio way more informative, Murphy looked wooden, totally inexperienced, and really didn’t do anything with 4 years in Congress. At 33 years old, he just isn’t ready to be a US Senator. Rubio is respected in DC, and I believe he will give Florida way more clout to get things done. Rubio earned my vote.

    • MRH - for the people

      October 23, 2016 at 9:57 am

      You are independent and undecided??? Right. Rubio – “Water boy” as I like to refer to him after his State of the Union response, will jump ship as soon as the opportunity comes up for him. Sticking with Trump after everything that has happened and the way they belittled each other in the Rep. primary shows to me Rubio’s true colors. I will take a 33-year-old individual who stands up for women’s rights and LGBT and health care expansion any time. Rubio’s flip flop on his statement of retiring from politics if he lost the nomination for President is still another reason why “Little Marco” needs to lose.

  • Richard Palais

    October 27, 2016 at 3:13 am

    Rubio was the clear winner of the debate.Murphy is just another commie-crat libtard who will do nothing but want to raise taxes on everyone and follow hil-liar-y!

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn