Rays to split season between St. Pete and Montreal? Don’t count on it

rays grass
Al Lang Field could be necessary to make the idea work.

Just as President Donald Trump can dictate an entire news cycle with a single tweet, the Rays have done the same in Tampa Bay.

They are sending the entire region (and baseball world) into a frenzy by leaking news that they want to explore splitting their 81-game home schedule between two markets, Tampa Bay and Montreal.

However, as with any sensational tweet, it’s important to sometimes take a step back and ask, ” … is this realistic?”

Because in the case of the Rays, a split season may be nothing more than fodder to fill a news rundown. It also appears to be a possible way for the franchise and Major League Baseball to leverage public opinion on the stadium stalemate in Tampa Bay.

By the time this story is published, every news site across West/Central Florida will have posted a report detailing the unprecedented split-season idea thrown out by the Rays and MLB, a concept team owner Stu Sternberg said (in a prepared statement) was “worthy of serious exploration.”

But let’s focus on how much of a long shot this idea is. Not only did St. Pete Mayor Rick Kriseman say his city already shot the idea down (the Rays cannot talk to other cities about home games outside the Trop prior to 2027), but the money also doesn’t make sense.

Even if the Rays and MLB got the required permission from St. Petersburg’s city council to explore the idea (they’re prohibited from talking to other cities about home games outside the Trop prior to 2027), the money doesn’t make sense.

Neither Tampa nor Montreal have been close to cobbling together the billion dollars necessary to build a new stadium for 81 home games, so it doesn’t seem very likely they’d have more luck on a stadium for only 40-ish games.

And St. Petersburg, which has been anxious to move past this never-ending soap opera so it can redevelop its 85 acres of prime downtown land before the economy slows down — with or without the Rays — would have very little to gain by continuing to subsidize a team that’s home only 40 nights a year while leaving a giant gaping hole in its redevelopment plans the other 325 nights.

Of course, as White Sox owner Jerry Reinsdorf pointed out after using Tampa Bay to get himself a new Chicago stadium, “a savvy negotiator creates leverage.”

So what are the Rays and MLB trying to leverage? Three possibilities:

1. Maybe Sternberg really does believe some best-of-both-worlds situation exists where he can keep the fan base he’s built up in Tampa Bay while also landing a new subsidized stadium in baseball-starved Montreal. But Sternberg, an astute businessman, knows this is unlikely.

2. Maybe it’s the next step in the team fleeing to Canada. Former St. Pete Mayor Bill Foster, who has always claimed Canada was Sternberg’s endgame, said Thursday in quite unflattering terms, “this is the Rays’ way to mitigate damages to (St. Pete) while they transition to a permanent home in Montreal … the Rays want a wife and a mistress, and believe that everyone should be fine with that. That’s not how this works. It’s time to show the Rays the door right now … they don’t deserve St. Pete.”

3. Despite all his frustrations, there are two things Sternberg loves about St. Petersburg: the waterfront, where he initially pitched a new stadium in 2008, and the Trop site redevelopment revenues he stands to collect 50 percent of, for as long as the Rays play ball in St. Pete. So could Sternberg be envisioning a future where the Rays play 41 games a year at Al Lang Stadium (which he now controls through his ownership of the Rowdies) while also collecting revenues from the city’s redevelopment rights where the Trop currently sits?

As President Trump’s tweets remind us, everything is negotiable.

In fact, it’s worth pointing out that during last year’s Ybor City stadium press conference, where Sternberg was pitching a Rays move across the bay, he still seemed interested in finding a way to tap that St. Petersburg redevelopment money, even after he left the Trop.

So while neither the Rays nor MLB are hurting for money, businesses don’t profit off new stadiums if they have to pay for them themselves.

“I have great respect for Stu Sternberg and his leadership team,” Mayor Kriseman said during a late-afternoon press conference Thursday. “But after 12 years of indecision, including three years of exploring his options (in Tampa) … like many in Tampa Bay, I am tired of the games being played in the name of getting a stadium built … we all deserve better and should not take this too seriously.”

Kriseman, who had refrained from criticizing Sternberg in recent years, took a number of additional jabs at the Rays’ owner.

The Mayor accused Sternberg of negotiating through the press on an idea that had already been rejected, as well as the team’s informal policy of not talking publicly about a stadium during the baseball season.

However, Kriseman says he remains interested in sitting down with the team to discuss its future so both the city and the Rays can move forward.

Ironically, this week marks the nine-year anniversary of Sternberg’s ultimatum to St. Petersburg that it could either help him find a new stadium or the team would have to move on.

Noah Pransky

Noah Pransky is a multiple award-winning investigative reporter, most recently with the CBS affiliate in Tampa. He’s uncovered major stories such as uncovering backroom deals in the Tampa Bay Rays stadium and other political investigations. Pransky also ran a blog called Shadow of the Stadium, giving readers a deep dive into the details of potential financial deals and other happenings involving the Tampa Bay- area sports business.


  • AdieuRayons!

    June 20, 2019 at 3:57 pm

    Absurd! As usual, Snuffy Sternberg wants his cake and wants to eat it, too! Hopefully, St. Pete holds him to the Tropicana contract and, if he chooses to leave for Montreal early, he has to buy out the remainder of the contract … and if he wants to chitchat with Montreal about renovating their old stadium or building a new one … he’ll have to pay dearly for another MOU! it was a sad day in St. Pete when Sternberg came to town!

  • Eltweed

    June 20, 2019 at 4:01 pm

    How would this effects their new $82 Million/15 Year contract with Fox Sports – “local” viewership is very high and when that drops, so does advertising. Games in a smaller TV market, let alone outside the USA will place this contract in jeopardy. Mismanagement from New York ownership has almost eliminated local funding for a stadium.

  • Wayne Turiansky

    June 20, 2019 at 4:41 pm

    One correction, Noah. The Bronfman/Garber/Bell team in Montreal is not asking for any public money for the new ballpark in Montreal. They already have a contract on the land. I imagine they will want some infrastructure developed (the light rail station is already in the plans) and some tax abatement on the land on which the park will sit.

  • Hal Freedman

    June 21, 2019 at 5:42 pm

    Very dumb idea. The Rays won’t go to Al Lang Field. All they have there is what’s left of a 5-year Bill Edwards lease. To extend it to 25 years or more, they would have to go to referendum again for the waterfront park land. The recently passed referendum for a longer lease, is contingent on getting a Major League Soccer (MLS) franchise and using the stadium primarily for soccer. If they tried to move to the Waterfront, POWW would rise from the dead, this time with funding for what was a grassroots organization the last time around. The Rays would never win a referendum for long-term use of our City Charter protected Waterfront Park land.

    My suggestion: let them buy out of St. Petersburg as soon as they like, and go wherever they wish. The buyout price…give up their share of development rights for the Trop site, and give up their veto power, so the City can begin redevelopment sooner than later.

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn