Term limits sound great and generally seem popular with voters. I’m not a fan, though, because the cure can be worse than the disease. Forcing effective lawmakers from office because of an arbitrary number usually means the newcomer has a steep learning curve.
Just who will do the teaching?
Special interests, of course.
With that in mind, there is reason to be leery of an idea kicking around the Hillsborough County Charter Review Board. It would close the loophole that allows County Commissioners to skirt the two-term limit voters approved in the 1980s.
That law limits commissioners to a pair of four-year terms in one district. However, when their time runs out in, say, a single-member district, they can hop to a county-wide district. It goes on all the time.
Commissioner Ken Hagen has worked the game better than anyone. He was first elected in 2002 and has bounced from single-member, to countywide, back to single-member.
Sure, that violates the spirit of what voters approved back in the day. He keeps winning elections, though, so that must say something about how the electorate feels about him.
On the other side, consider now-former commissioners Victor Crist and Sandy Murman. Both long-serving commissioners lost their bids to represent new districts.
The system works.
The phrase “career politician” ignores the value of experienced leadership.
“We have term limits, it’s called the ballot box,” review board member Mary Figg said at the meeting. “If the citizens — the voters — want to keep a representative for 3o years, why not, it’s their vote.”
She’s not wrong.
We have term limits in Tallahassee, you know. No more than two terms in the House or Senate, although lawmakers can jump from one body to the other.
Some folks believe the limits hurt more than they help.
“It’s not going to change,” Democratic consultant and former state House member Dick Batchelor told the Orlando Sentinel in 2019.
“The people are not going to support additional time in office. And the price we pay in exchange for that is more turnover of elected officials and an exponential increase in the influence of lobbyists and staff.”
In the same story, state Rep. Carlos Guillermo Smith noted, “Tallahassee is broken. Session is too quick, term limits are too short and lawmakers are paid too little.”
He’s got a point, and the Hillsborough review board should listen.
Voters can – and do – impose term limits all by themselves.
They don’t need extra help.