Gabrielle Russon
Two families are suing Universal Orlando after a “Despicable Me” costumed character appeared to flash a White power hand symbol in photo shoots with their children during two separate incidents in 2019, according to a newly filed lawsuit.
At a Universal hotel character breakfast, Tiffiney and Richard Zinger’s then-6-year-old daughter was a fan of the Minions, so she was excited to meet the film franchise’s main character, Felonious Gru, said the girl’s mother.
The child, who is biracial and has autism, stood next to Gru for a picture while the character made the ‘OK’ hand gesture — a symbol hijacked by White supremacists — over her shoulder, the Orange Circuit Court lawsuit filed late last month said.
“It was heartbreaking. I was pretty sad, upset, everything all at once. How could someone do this to a child?” said Tiffiney Zinger, who noticed the gesture for the first time when her son was going through family photos for a school project.
The March 2019 incident at Universal’s Loews Royal Pacific Resort garnered national media attention that year, and a theme park spokesman later acknowledged the employee playing Gru had been fired.
“We never want our guests to experience what this family did. This is not acceptable, and we are sorry — and we are taking steps to make sure nothing like this happens again. We can’t discuss specifics about this incident, but we can confirm that the actor no longer works here. We remain in contact with the family and will work with them privately to make this right,” spokesman Tom Schroder said in a statement at the time to USA Today.
Universal did not immediately respond to a request for comment about the lawsuit this week.
It wasn’t the only time the character made the symbol with children, the lawsuit alleged.
A second family with a similar experience emerged after reading the initial media coverage, said Lisa Riddle, the Miami lawyer who filed the new lawsuit seeking unspecified damages for intentionally inflicting emotional distress, violating the Florida Civil Rights Law and other allegations.
Joel Rodriguez recalled an odd interaction with the same masked character when his daughter, who is Hispanic and lives near Fort Myers, visited Universal Studios Florida theme park in February 2019, about a month before the Zingers, Riddle said.
“The father remembered that the character dressed as Gru had been acting very strangely towards him and his daughter. He had pretty much begged the character to come and stand in a picture with his daughter,” Riddle said.
The Rodriguez family scrolled through their old photos and looked closer, Riddle said. One photo stood out: Their then-5-year-old daughter holding Gru’s hand while the character made the ‘OK’ symbol with his other hand, according to the lawsuit.
The child’s parents, Rodriguez and Geisy Moreno, are now suing Universal along with the Zingers.
The photographs of the two children posing with Gru are included in the lawsuit.
“The two young vulnerable children gleefully and innocently ran up to meet the disguised man during family trips to Universal Orlando-sponsored events,” the lawsuit said, “In display of open hatred towards the girls, the costumed man made a White-Power hand symbol while posing for family photographs and videos taken by their unsuspecting parents.”
When asked if she thought the character may have posed with additional children beyond the two known cases, Riddle said, “It certainly causes serious concern when you see the exact same dress character doing this over very distinct periods of time.”
Universal declined to give the attorney details on the terminated employee’s identity, or if it was multiple people dressed as Gru during the two incidents, Riddle said.
“One of the first and foremost things we wanted was to know the identity of the employee who was doing this. Universal did not give that information to us, so now, one method we can use to get that information is through the lawsuit. They forced us to do that,” Riddle said.
According to court documents, the attorney is seeking to obtain the personnel file for the theme park worker depicted in the photographs, as well as discrimination complaints made against employees.
Tiffiney Zinger said the photo prompted her to have a deeper conversation with her two children about racism and how people treat others.
“They understand that someone did something bad to them, and it’s not OK,” she said.
Her daughter, now 9, lives in both Colorado and the Orlando suburbs.
The lawsuit comes more than two years after the families’ visits. Before Riddle filed the lawsuit, she said she needed to file a complaint with the Florida Commission on Human Relations, which she said ultimately did not issue a decision on the case last year after a monthslong investigation.
The state commission created to prevent unlawful discrimination and enforce the Florida Civil Rights Act does not comment on individual cases, a spokesman said Wednesday.
The ‘OK’ sign, where the thumb and index finger make a circle, is almost universally known as a positive sign, but in recent years the meaning has changed as white supremacists have taken it up as a symbol, said Susan Corke, Southern Poverty Law Center’s Intelligence Project director.
“A lot of the time, it is used completely innocuously, but that’s kind of the point of it,” Corke said. For White supremacists, “a plausible deniability is built into it.”
The symbol’s connection to White supremacy started as a hoax around 2017 on 4chan, an alternative right anonymous online message board. The plan was to flood mainstream social media channels with messages calling the OK symbol the new way to signify White power in a move meant to troll liberals and journalists, Corke said.
“It started out as a hoax, but the hoax became real,” Corke said.
Images later depicted people flashing the hand signal from a smirking police officer at a Black Lives Matter rally to White supremacist leader Richard Spencer or Republican strategist Roger Stone making the gesture with the Proud Boys, a far-right group, she said.
Images via Orange Circuit Court.
20 comments
zhombre
July 7, 2021 at 6:26 pm
Sounds like total BS, a frivolous lawsuit. Paranoia about alleged white supremacy hand signals that the media, irresponsibly, is promulgating.
Sue
July 7, 2021 at 8:49 pm
Agree, I didn’t even know about the hand jester
John
July 8, 2021 at 7:06 am
Bahahahaha.
This reads like satire.
Lulu
July 8, 2021 at 9:22 am
I do that with my hand is well. I didn’t know it was illegal to put your fingers together. This is nonsense and crazy. That loss it should be thrown at that lady’s face
Sam
July 9, 2021 at 12:57 am
This is stupid I’m sorry
Nunya
July 9, 2021 at 3:01 am
Fucking retards
Dick Brenson
July 9, 2021 at 6:19 am
Bollocks
martin
July 9, 2021 at 4:08 pm
Oh Pluh-Ease. Everything has now become “racist”. This is one jury I would love to sit on. Verdict-for the defense.
Patricia Ann Binkley
July 10, 2021 at 8:09 am
It’s all about the kids let’s not forget this PARENTS.
Please Leave The Theme Park’s alone Parents.
Jamie
July 10, 2021 at 10:45 pm
It’s crazy how this is a game in school how is it anything to do with racism. They reaching
Kristin
July 14, 2021 at 8:41 am
My thought exactly!! I’m 40 years old and went to HS in Philadelphia.. very diverse… my memories of this game include it being played regularly by my black friends! It’s not racist!
ficke ngeil
July 11, 2021 at 10:09 am
safe to say that the author grew up without having any friends
try getting back into reality, you sad twat
Ron Ogden
July 12, 2021 at 6:04 am
People can stick their middle fingers in the air and it’s. . .OK. The filing of lawsuits over hand gestures is mere game playing on the part of people who wish to condemn American culture with every opportunity they get–and make a few bucks into the bargain. If ever there were cases that deserve to be thrown out of court for the sake of trying to retrieve the vestiges of sanity in jurisprudence, these cases are the ones.
test
July 12, 2021 at 9:25 am
If the article is true its also Embarrassing….
Anyone can do mistakes, but doing it again after you got sued is just embarrassing for human intelligence..
They were not just told that it meant “white power”, they got it on paper/written! And still doing it on purpose.
He or She should have notice by know that they are working in a family team park, but Universal Orlando may have told the employee to not bother.
What if the employees are tricked to do the “OK” sign semi-hidden when posing in pics?
Universal Orlando do support racism?
Or it could me another employee, tricking the new employee by doing the OK sign, cause he or she remember the drama last time.
There will always be stupid people around.
ANd for thoose who say that its stupid to even bother about the sign, well your in the same boat as mr.racist. EMploee didnt bother to stop, it could mean that they want the attention as well,
I have read the article now, a little thin but I’m sure I will remember the meaning in 6 months as well.
-Just Heat it up!
Noddy
July 13, 2021 at 1:38 am
Are you fucking stupid he did both the photos before even getting fired the worker didn’t get sued, these photos were also taken 3yrs ago when this gesture actually meant “Okay” the only reason this dumb family is filing a lawsuit against Universal now is because they think they can get big bucks after 4chan users made memes saying the “Okay” symbol is racist to see if mainstream media would believe it and what do you know they ate it up and made everyone believe that “Okay” hand gesture is racist, you can also see in one of the photos the little boy is also holding up the gesture type into your phones keyboard “Okay” and see what emoji pops up it will be the “Okay” hand gesture used by scuba divers and deaf people 👌
zhombre
July 14, 2021 at 8:57 am
Yes, there will always be stupid people around. Especially if you reproduce.
Punkster12
July 14, 2021 at 5:39 pm
There is certainly a probability that the guy was racist. Simultaneously, that is more than just a racist symbol. As the article said, it was “HIJACKED.” People do that symbol without any racial intention whatsoever. So Yes there is a probability that the guy is racist and he meant to do it as a hate symbol, BUT there is also a massive probability that this was a completely meaningless “at the moment” hand gesture with innocent intentions. They’re assuming a lot here.
Not floridaman lol
July 14, 2021 at 11:19 pm
Definitely the racist wp sign.
Innocent ok symbols are performed upright with the fingers pointing happily high in the air
Comments are closed.