Where does sh*t stand — the “legislative food fights” edition
Rally-goers protest at the Michigan State Capitol in Lansing, Mich. Image via AP.

Editor’s note: As the 2015 Legislative Session kicks into high gear, FloridaPolitics.com is continuing to report on several “legislative food fights” during the annual lawmaking period. These kerfuffles don’t always make the front page of the traditional media outlets, but they are the kind of industry vs. industry or intra-industry turf battles that drive Tallahassee — and expand the field of play for state lobbyists. Here’s a look at where sh*t stands heading into the third week of Session.

Big tobacco vs. Florida trial attorneys: The four tobacco industry defendants in the 1998 Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement are now pursuing a bill that would retroactively limit their exposure in that case.

Naples Republican Sen. Garrett Richter and Rep. David Santiago, a Republican of Deltona, are both running bills that would apply limitations on punitive damages to all civil actions in which a judgment has not been entered. Those include about 4,000 claimants in the Big Tobacco settlement. Richter’s SB 978 has emerged from the slush pile and received a relatively short path to a full Senate vote, facing just two committees in Judiciary and Rules. The House version of the bill has also received just two assignments — Civil Justice and Judiciary — but neither bill has yet been considered or calendared.

Optometrists vs. 1-800-Contacts: As we wrote in February, ambiguity in a federal regulatory battle concerning the legality of major contact manufacturers cooperating to create “unilateral pricing policies” — i.e. establishing price floors below which their products cannot be sold — set up a state-by-state legislative battle over who can sell their contacts directly to the public and how they can do it. Brandon Republican Sen. Tom Lee filed SB 1400, which would restrict the upstart independent retailers and help the optometrists maintain their dominance in the market.

Since then the bill has been referred to a slate of committees, namely Health Policy, Commerce & Tourism, and Appropriations, but it has not been heard. A House companion sponsored by Orlando Republican Rep. Eric Eisnaugle, HB 1119, has received committee referrals as well, and also has not moved.

Ticketmaster vs. StubHub: Our 2015 preview of this legislative donnybrook explained how Ticketmaster is seeking to expand its near-monopoly on major event ticket sales by redefining tickets as “revocable licenses” rather than personal property belonging to its owner upon purchase. That would force StubHub and shoe-leather scalpers everywhere to receive permission from Ticketmaster to resell tickets purchased from them, permission the company would almost certainly be tight with in the extreme.

RPOF Chairman and Spring Hill Rep. Blaise Ingoglia filed a bill to do just that in HB 463. That bill continues to sit in the Business & Professions Subcommittee, where it has lain dormant since January. Its Senate companion, SB 742 by Sen. Wilton Simpson, a Republican of Trilby, is also currently inert, having been referred to three committees but not taken up.

Major airline carriers vs. Mid-major carriers: This explosive imbroglio over jet fuel taxes features legislation that so far has reached higher altitudes than that of most of the above. Delta and American Airlines were left out of a fuel tax rebate granted to several smaller carriers in order to bolster Florida’s air travel industry amid post-9/11 fears of flagging business and tourism. But the carriers who benefit from the rebate — including SouthwestJet BlueAirTran and Spirit — have now done well for years in an improving economic climate, and the big boys now say it amounts to an unfair advantage.

Miami Republican Sen. Anitere FloresSB 722 and HB 595 by Rep. George Moraitis, a Fort Lauderdale Republican, seek to change that by deleting that rebate provision — and while they’re at it, also lowers the rate of the jet fuel tax from 6.9 cents per gallon to 5.4 cents per gallon. Both bills sit in their second of three committee assignments, House and Senate Finance & Tax, respectively. Moraitis’ bill was approved by Tourism & Economic Development on the first day of Session, with Reps. Dane Eagle of Cape Coral and Mike La Rosa of St. Cloud casting “No” votes. The Senate companion was given permission to take off in Transportation, where it was unanimously approved two days later.

Uber vs. Florida Taxicab Association: By far the most visible statehouse food fight to the apolitical public, the battle to allow ridesharing services like Uber and Lyft to operate without running afoul of local ordinances prohibiting their operations, has made uneven progress so far.

Shalimar Republican Rep. Matt Gaetz’s HB 817 was approved in House Transportation & Ports, with three Democrats casting “No” votes — probably not an obstacle that gives Capitol watchers much pause. On the other hand SB 1326, sponsored by Uber’s most visible champion Sen. Jeff Brandes, GOP member of St. Petersburg, has not yet been taken up in committee nor has it been calendared. When it does come up in its first stop in Regulated Industries, it’ll be interesting to see whether committee member Sen. Jack Latvala, Republican of Palm Harbor, takes an interest in the debate.

Ryan Ray

Ryan Ray covers politics and public policy in North Florida and across the state. He has also worked as a legislative researcher and political campaign staffer. He can be reached at [email protected]


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Jason Delgado, Renzo Downey, Rick Flagg, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Joe Henderson, Janelle Irwin, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Jesse Scheckner, Scott Powers, Andrew Wilson, and Kelly Hayes.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn