Harvard’s NiemanLab retracts its inclusion of Florida Phoenix on ‘hyper partisan’ list
Stock image via Adobe.

The group's retraction leaves only conservative sites on the Florida list.

Editor’s Note: Since publishing our original story Tuesday morning, NiemanLab has since removed Florida Phoenix and all other States Newsroom publications from its list of “hyper partisan sites that are “masquerading as local news.”

Because of that, we have removed references to Florida Phoenix in this story to reflect NiemanLab’s correspondence explaining their decision.

“A previous version of this article and map included the 16 newsrooms of States Newsroom, a nonprofit network of local news sites that previously received backing from the liberal Hopewell Fund and did not begin disclosing its donors until this year. Its sites cannot be accurately described as “hyperpartisan sites…masquerading as local news,” and many of its staff are longtime journalists,” the group wrote in retraction.

The group’s decision came after Mary Cornatzer, States Newsroom’s national editor, wrote to them.

“Our Georgia editor is on the board of the Georgia First Amendment Foundation; our Virginia editor and two of his staff members were on the Richmond Times Dispatch staff; our Iowa editor has covered Iowa politics for 30 years and was most recently a political columnist and then opinion page editor for the Des Moines Register; our Louisiana editor was on the Times Picayune team that won the Pulitzer for Katrina coverage; our Florida editor covered schools for the Chicago Tribune for many many years. I could go on and on. All staff bios are listed on each newsroom’s website,” that correspondence read.

An updated version of our previous story is below.


NiemanLab, an arm of Harvard aimed at promoting and elevating the standards of journalism, listed more than 400 partisan media outlets nationwide.

The roundup included 14 Florida sites, all conservative.

The Nieman Lab analysis found most of the identified sites were “often funded and operated by government officials, political candidates, PACs, and political party operatives,” though they didn’t break out individual outlets to list which publications were culprits.

The analysis found that “these outlets are emerging most often in swing states.”

“We found that while left-leaning sites prioritize statewide reporting, right-leaning sites are more focused on local reporting, suggesting different strategies for engaging with targeted audiences and indicating the potential for these sites to exacerbate polarization in local communities,” the analysis reads.

The NiemanLab analysis outlines almost exclusively conservative sites as the main culprits of biased reporting, with only 8 of the 429 sites identified leaning left.

The analysis used research by Priyanjana Bengani at Columbia University’s Tow Center for Digital Journalism, which identified 450 sites that are part of 12 state networks operated by five corporate entities.

Bengani’s analysis used website registrant information from the WHOIS database, shared IP addresses and shared analytics identifiers to identify the scope and boundaries of networks, the analysis described.

“This kind of detailed detective work was necessary because these sites are often opaque about their ownership and/or financial backing,” authors wrote.

“This is a preliminary and basic analysis. However, it points toward a troubling reality. First, to the extent that these types of sites continue to proliferate and possibly replace traditional local news organizations, the partisanship that has come to characterize our national-level journalism could increasingly characterize our local journalism, potentially amplifying the political polarization that is already affecting the country, and potentially undermining effective self-governance at the local level.”

NiemanLab hopes to use the data in future research to identify whether partisan sites produce misinformation more often that traditional media.

“If that is the case, it could have significant implications for well-informed local self-governance,” the analysis reads.

The sites identified in Florida, all conservative, include:

—Florida Guide in the Panhandle

— Port St. Joe Guide in the Panhandle

— Perry Guide, southeast of Tallahassee

— Lake Butler News, west of Jacksonville

— Apopka times, Central Florida

— Maitland Today, Central Florida

— Goldenrod News, Central Florida

— Ocoee Today, Central Florida

— Windermere Today, Central Florida

  Wadeview Park News, Central Florida

— Doctor Phillips today, Central Florida

— College Park Today, Central Florida

— Baldwin Park Today, Central Florida

— Indiantown Guide, near Lake Okeechobee

Janelle Irwin Taylor

Janelle Irwin Taylor has been a professional journalist covering local news and politics in Tampa Bay since 2003. Most recently, Janelle reported for the Tampa Bay Business Journal. She formerly served as senior reporter for WMNF News. Janelle has a lust for politics and policy. When she’s not bringing you the day’s news, you might find Janelle enjoying nature with her husband, children and two dogs. You can reach Janelle at [email protected].

One comment

  • Sonja Fitch

    July 17, 2020 at 6:13 am

    Our local papers controlled by “corporate” greed is a failure of Free Press! But the local papers once the community figures this out are going to ignore and not buy the corporate greed and lies!

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704