Joe Henderson
You live in Pasco County and have one or two run-ins with the Sheriff’s Office on your record. Maybe it wasn’t a major crime, but that doesn’t matter. It’s late, and you’re headed to bed, when … BAM! BAM!
Someone is pounding on the door, and without looking, you know who it is because they’ve been there many times before. Pasco County deputies are just checking to see what you’re doing.
They know where you live and want you to remember that. They are always watching.
This sounds like an Orwellian nightmare. According to a scalding Tampa Bay Times investigative report, though, it’s a reality for those caught in the net of the Intelligence-Led Policing program incorporated by Sheriff Chris Nocco. It’s designed to identify people likely to commit a crime.
The concept is not new. Police departments in several cities around the country use computer models to predict where crimes might occur and who the guilty parties might be. In 2001, Tampa posted three dozen facial recognition cameras in Ybor City but took them down a couple of years later after no results.
Cameras have been used in Super Bowl host cities, including Tampa, to monitor possible terrorists.
And Tampa Mayor Jane Castor admitted a program that targeted Black bicyclists when she was the city’s Police Chief was wrong.
That said, the Pasco program, according to the Times report, takes this idea to a different level. After the computer identifies people to target, deputies take it from there.
“They swarm homes in the middle of the night, waking families and embarrassing people in front of their neighbors,” the Times reported. “They write tickets for missing mailbox numbers and overgrown grass, saddling residents with court dates and fines.”
And, the Times concluded, “They come again and again, making arrests for any reason they can.”
One former deputy described the directive like this to the Times: “Make their lives miserable until they move or sue.”
The Times had bodycam footage of some of the interactions. Imagine this happening at your house.
The Sheriff’s response is that the ends justify the means.
“We again would like to reiterate our firm stance that Intelligence-Led Policing has worked to reduce property crimes in Pasco County and continues to work in agencies in our area that also use this model such as Hillsborough County,” the Office said in a lengthy retort.
“This reduction in property crimes includes a 74.4% reduction in residential burglaries and a 20.7% reduction in auto thefts, along with an overall reduction of property crimes of 35.6%.”
That data was from 2011 when Nocco became Sheriff through 2019.
From dispatch logs, the Times reported deputies executed more than 12,500 of these “visits” since 2015. And about 10% of those trips were aimed at individuals under 18. To be fair, Nocco is popular with most Pasco residents. Supporters believe he is doing what he must to protect them.
But harassment on this scale as a police tactic goes over the line. Deputies don’t bring warrants and don’t have probable cause. They just show up, repeatedly.
I’m not a lawyer, but an argument can be made this violates the Fourth Amendment.
It states, “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated …”
Pasco has moved to the edge of unreasonable, and maybe a step or two over.
2 comments
FLnative44
September 10, 2020 at 11:37 am
I kinda sorta have to agree with you re the nanny state aspects of this policy and the practices following being ”orwellian”..
So, IMO, ya kinda got to take your choice between that kind of clearly promulgated policies and practices, and the ”irregular” practices of the 1940 -50 era in Sarasota, where some folks were not allowed on the streets after dark, and any ”stranger” was stopped by police and checked out, and better have a good story. SRQ cops were well known for beating folks if not obedient, breaking legs the second time, just burying them in the orange groves east of town the third time; this went for some of the criminal folks who came back with the circus each winter, no matter who they were.
Same thing in Naples in the early 60s, but cops there would also stop any vehicle they didn’t know, ask for ID, address, etc.
Both places had very little crime of any kind except ”passion.” (There was a killing almost every weekend at the Red Barn in east Naples, and it was told that Gator McGill was in Raiford for killing two guys who jumped him there, in spite of testimony he was acting in self defense.)
Tom
September 12, 2020 at 12:39 pm
The Pasco policing policy is clearly unreasonable and therefore unconstitutional. When Donald Trump hears about this, Sheriff Nocco will surely get invited to the White House for a Thataboy photo op with the prez.
Comments are closed.