Jesse Scheckner
Two clear winners emerged Tuesday in a General Election for three Miami Beach Commission seats. A third was confirmed the victor with a razor-thin lead just outside the recount threshold Thursday.
With all 21 precincts reporting Tuesday, the undeniable winners were marketing professionals Tanya Katzoff Bhatt and David Suarez, who will take the Group 4 and 5 seats on the Commission, respectively.
A third race between finance pro Joe Magazine and art consultant Marcella Novela in Group 6 came down to the wire. Magazine won by just 67 votes (0.52 percentage points). Had the margin been 0.03 points smaller, a recount would have been necessary.
Bhatt, a Democrat, defeated real estate broker Andres Asion, a no-party candidate, with 56.5% of the vote to succeed Vice Mayor Steven Meiner. Meiner is leaving office for a mayoral bid.
In the race to replace term-limited Commissioner Ricky Arriola, Suarez, a no-party candidate, outpaced Democratic hotelier Mitch Novick with 52.5% of the vote.
Magazine led Novela on Election Day. Following a ballot-curing process that ended 5 p.m. Thursday, that lead remained.
Magazine’s campaign declared victory Tuesday night.
“I am humbled and honored by the support I received from Miami Beach voters who have elected me as our next City Commissioner,” he said in a statement. “Together, we will fight to ensure Miami Beach works for families, treats everyone equally, and focuses on a resilient future. From the bottom of my heart, thank you for the opportunity to serve the community I love and where I’m proudly raising my daughter.”
None of the six candidates running had prior elected experience, though all were active in the community they hoped to serve prior to filing this year. And while there was ample overlap in policy positions among them, each managed to distinguish themselves enough to provide voters a clear choice.
The top issue for Miami Beach residents this year — and the candidates seeking their support — was public safety. In the past three years, Miami Beach has imposed curfews to curb violent disorder in the city’s nightlife hotspots after shootings during spring break.
One potential fix a majority of voters supported through a nonbinding straw ballot item in 2021 is a proposed alcohol sales cutoff in the city’s entertainment district at 2 a.m., three hours earlier than the current 5 a.m. last call.
In all but one of the races, the candidates largely agreed on the matter.
Also weighing heavily were concerns of overdevelopment, including the potential replacement of historical neighborhoods and buildings with new structures that, while more resilient, may be incompatible with the character of the neighborhood.
The Miami Beach Commission and its elections are technically nonpartisan. Commissioners serve in an at-large capacity, representing the entire city. Commission terms are four years.
Group 4
Despite filing one month after Bhatt, Asion held the edge in fundraising. As of Oct. 20, he collected $190,000 through his campaign account. A significant chunk came from real estate businesses and professionals.
His political committee, Defending Democracy PC, was chaired by consultant Christian Ulvert and raised $47,000 since the 2022 election, nearly all of it from real estate interests.
Bhatt took in more than $151,000 through her campaign account since filing for the race in February. An overwhelming portion of it came from individual donors.
An electioneering communications organization (ECO) supporting her campaign called Miami Beach for All of Us raised an additional $44,000. Most of the funds came from real estate businesses.
Bhatt also enjoyed support from the Miami Herald and SAVE Action PAC, an LGBTQ advocacy organization. Asion told the Miami Herald he’d donated thousands of dollars to the group.
Asion, 48, is a former Republican whose firm, Miami Real Estate Group, specializes in high-rise development sales. He also runs an eponymous nonprofit that has drawn praise from city and county officials for its work during the pandemic.
In spite of his day job, he maintained during the campaign that he wanted to tamp down on irresponsible growth in the city. His campaign website also listed incentivizing residential property owners to keep rents down and helping homeowners improve their properties’ resilience as priorities.
That approach, he said, would “make sure the unique character of each neighborhood is taken into account when planning for sea level rise and when improving our existing infrastructure.”
He sits on the Miami Beach Board of Adjustment and used to work as an administrative assistant to Xavier Suarez, a former Miami Mayor, Miami-Dade County Commissioner and the father of Miami Mayor Francis Suarez.
Bhatt, 56, owns the marketing firm LaunchBrand and sits on the Miami Beach Planning Board and Miami Design Preservation League. Previously, she served as President of Miami Beach United, a nonprofit resident advocacy organization.
While campaigning, said she wanted to lead Miami Beach toward having a better law enforcement approach to cracking down on spring break misconduct and other public safety issues. She floated the use of license plate readers to “stop dangerous individuals from roaring across our causeway in cars loaded with guns and drugs.”
Other priorities included improving traffic, prioritizing sewer and stormwater projects over additional development in the city and preserving historical structures. Bhatt also wanted to reform permitting, arguing it “should not take four years to open a restaurant.”
The two candidates were split on the 2 a.m. last call issue, according to a Herald survey of candidates. Asion was against the change, calling it a “one-size-fits-all solution that does not consider the diverse needs” of the city’s entertainment district. Bhatt said she was for following through on voters’ preference by not granting any new 5 a.m. licenses while allowing bars with existing ones to continue operating as long as they remain in good legal standing.
This year, a social media account called No MAGA Takeover Miami Beach uncovered past social media posts by several candidates, including Asion, who in a since-deleted post to social media called Republican Ron DeSantis “the best Governor in the country.”
Asion later explained he was referring only to DeSantis’ early elimination of COVID restrictions, not his culture war policies. He said he is for reproductive rights, LGBTQ rights and has a gay brother.
Group 5
Both Novick and Suarez supported the 2 a.m. last call rollback and included policies boosting law enforcement efforts in the city. They differed on other issues.
Suarez raised $651,000 since filing in March. All but $30,000 came from his bank account. Among that sum was $3,000 from Mango’s Tropical Café, a related business and the café’s owner, David Wallack, who opposed the 2 a.m. last call.
Groups endorsing Suarez included the Fraternal Order of Police, Miami Beach Firefighters, Communications Workers of America, South Florida AFL-CIO and SOBE Safe, a volunteer community watch group.
Both candidates had past run-ins with the law. Novick was arrested in 2017 for allegedly stealing towels from Mango’s. He said Wallack had given him permission, and the charges were later dropped.
Suarez was arrested in 2003 for burglary during what he described to the Herald as a “high school prank.” Prosecutors did not pursue charges.
In 2020, a judge ordered Suarez to temporarily turn over at least 12 guns and his concealed carry permit after photographs showed his young son “in close proximity to a variety of different weapons” while at his home. Suarez said the guns all had locks on them, but that he’s since purchased safes in which to store them.
The Herald also reported that Suarez, who switched from Republican to having no party affiliation in 2021, made numerous donations to members of the national conservatism movement. Recipients included DeSantis, former President Donald Trump, Laura Loomer and Blake Masters, a former candidate for the U.S. Senate who promoted a theory that Democrats were encouraging immigrants to “change the demographics of this country.”
Novick, 59, owns the Sherbrook Hotel and has long advocated for historic preservation during his 35 years of residency, including as Chair of the Miami Beach Preservation Board and Miami-Dade Historic Preservation Board.
His platform focused on stopping crime in the entertainment district, strengthening city policies to further protect historic buildings and neighborhoods, safeguarding and adding to the city’s affordable housing portfolio and protecting residents from utility rate hikes.
He also wanted to improve public safety by first addressing the “attractive nuisance” of Ocean Drive and then funding police to enforce new rules curbing mischief in the area.
Suarez, 39, is the marketing director for skin care company LifeCell. He was born in Miami and is a board member of the Miami Beach Visitor and Convention Authority.
In 2021, he led a successful effort called Save SoFi to, among other things, stop short-term rentals in the South of Fifth neighborhood.
His platform prioritized improving public safety by expanding the police department, assigning police units to every neighborhood and reducing Miami Beach’s homeless population by “implementing more stringent rules on sleeping or camping on public property.”
He also wanted to improve the quality of neighborhoods by accelerating upgrades to sewer and stormwater systems, cracking down on noise complaints and passing legislation to discourage developments that convert residential properties for “transient use.”
Novick’s campaign account amassed $300,000 between July and Oct. 20, all of it his money. He carried endorsements from SAVE Action PAC and the Miami Herald.
Group 6
Magazine and Novela, both former Republicans, opposed the 2 a.m. last call but said public safety was an issue they’d work to improve if elected to the City Commission.
They competed to succeed Group 6 Commissioner David Richardson, a former state lawmaker who is leaving for a shot at being Miami-Dade County’s first elected Tax Collector in more than half a century.
Magazine, 40, is the Vice President of global investment services firm Loop Capital. He’s lived in Miami Beach for about a decade and sits on the Miami Beach Planning Board.
He said he wanted to provide police with additional resources, engage in “smart PR efforts” to discourage out-of-town partiers from visiting, reduce short-term rentals in the city and limit commercial uses in residential areas.
His website also mentioned clean energy and infrastructure projects as priorities. To further prevent crime during high-volume periods like spring break, he planned to “prevent performers with a history of violence from holding shows near us.”
Novela, 45, owns Art Conductor, an art consultancy and curation firm. She grew up in Miami-Dade, has lived in Miami Beach for 22 years and chairs the city’s Art in Public Places board.
She’s also a board member of the city’s 41st Street Committee and the Perez Art Museum Miami.
Her priorities included improving the safety of residents, reducing traffic with new light synchronization, street cleaning and city beautification, stepping up historic preservation efforts, funding micro-transit options like Freebee and stopping “runaway overdevelopment.”
Heading into the election’s home stretch, Novela held the advantage in funding due to a $100,000 loan her husband, real estate developer Richardo Dunin Borkowsky, gave her political committee, Elevate Miami Beach.
The political committee took $42,500 more from other sources in addition to $101,000 Novela raised through her campaign account, $20,000 of which was a self-loan.
Magazine raised $125,000 through his campaign, a fifth of which was self-given. Residents for Safe Neighborhoods, a political committee supporting him that Ulvert runs, took in $1,000.
Most of Magazine’s gains came through personal checks.
Like Suarez, Magazine scored endorsements from the Fraternal Order of Police, Miami Beach Firefighters, Communications Workers of America, South Florida AFL-CIO and SOBE Safe.
Novela won an endorsement from the Herald despite its reporting that she failed to disclose three now-dismissed foreclosures for unpaid utility bills. The outlet took greater issue with online outbursts Magazine had more than half a decade ago.
In 2016, one day after a man killed five Dallas police officers during a protest over the police killings of Alton Sterling and Philandro Castile, Magazine wrote in a Facebook post that he was “sick of hearing a bunch of f***king morons talk about whose lives matter.”
“To me, my family’s lives matter. My life matters,” he wrote. “And if anybody decides to try and jeopardize that, they’ll see how little their life matters to me.”
He lamented the post as “worded poorly,” but explained he was reacting emotionally to “two extremes coming together, bestowing violence upon our county.”
In another post, he shared a picture of himself wearing a “Trump 2016” hat and asserting he “supported Trump for over a year and a half.”
Magazine said he supports abortion rights, is an LGBTQ ally and voted for Biden in 2020. He canceled his Republican membership last year and now, like Novela, has no party affiliation.
No MAGA Takeover Miami Beach also flagged $1,000 donations Novela made last year to the campaigns of DeSantis and embattled Republican Rep. Fabián Basabe, who ran as a progressive before supporting many of the Governor’s policy proposals, including further restrictions on LGBTQ inclusion in public schools and bills loosening firearm regulations.
