New Florida college survey asks students: Does a vote for Donald Trump or Joe Biden end a friendship?
Image via Fresh Take Florida.

College UF University of Florida
The survey also contains several new questions this year related to protests and freedom of speech on campus.

The latest round of a controversial state survey of Florida college and university students includes a slew of new questions probing how their political views have affected relationships on campus — and whether it’s hard to be friends with people who have voted for Joe Biden or Donald Trump.

The anonymous and voluntary annual survey — which is loaded with ideological political and free speech questions — was distributed by email and text to public higher ed students and was to be completed by Friday. Some students said they viewed participation in the survey as a responsibility. Others, along with faculty members, expressed skepticism about the survey’s content, methodology and security.

Florida temporarily suspended the “intellectual freedom and viewpoint diversity” survey last year after distributing it for the first time in 2022, with a response rate of roughly 2% for students. The annual surveys are mandated by a law signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis in 2021 following Republican state lawmakers’ concerns about conservative views being suppressed on college campuses.

The law requires that the Board of Governors and the Board of Education “annually assess intellectual freedom and viewpoint diversity at certain institutions.” Faculty have yet to receive a survey this year as the law requires.

The student survey this year has 52 questions, more than double the previous version.

The Biden-Trump questions are asked separately. The survey says, Do you agree or disagree with the following statement: “It’s hard to be friends with people who voted for Joe Biden” and then the same question with Trump’s name instead of Biden’s. Students are given a range of possible answers, from strongly agree to strongly disagree.

“The fact that they actually named the Presidents — it really rubbed me the wrong way,” said Noah Barguez-Arias, 23, of Miami, a graduate student at the University of Florida (UF).

“It’s kind of gross, it’s kind of slimy,” she added. “I feel like the universities just shouldn’t really worry about that… It doesn’t really matter what political beliefs or whatever identifying thing students believe in or what their professors or (administration) believe in as long as everyone is safe from harm.”

Some other new politically pointed questions ask whether the student has been socially excluded, harassed or threatened for sharing political views, lost friends because of their political beliefs and witnessed students with either liberal or conservative views receive “uncivil treatment.”

The survey also contains several new questions this year related to protests and freedom of speech on campus. It asks what actions are appropriate to challenge demonstrators or speakers, including using violence or attempting to block other students from attending an event, and what students think of how their administration has handled such matters or how they should.

And it asks students about their comfort level in disagreeing with a professor on a controversial topic and expressing their opinions because of fear of reprisal.

“We didn’t want our members to be taken advantage of for any political interest at all, so we felt the need to communicate that to our members,” said Cassie Urbenz, communications co-chair of UF’s Graduate Assistants United, which urged members not to take the survey. “The data can very easily be manipulated.”

In a statement about the survey, a representative of the Florida College System, which includes 28 public community and state colleges, said colleges and universities should be where students are taught how to think, not what to think.

“The college campus is supposed to be a place where ideas can be freely discussed, weighed against each other, and informed conclusions can be drawn, and no student should feel alienated or persecuted for expressing their opinions in their college institutions,” the statement said.

Deanna Michael, an associate professor of higher education and policy at the University of South Florida, said too many of the survey questions focus on the dynamic between liberals and conservatives.

“Intellectual freedom and diversity is not really about political thought,” said Michael, a past Chair of the Board of Governors’ Advisory Council of Faculty Senates, adding that she isn’t sure whether she will take the survey this year.

On campuses, conservative students welcomed the questionnaire.

Natalie Schiffer, a 22-year-old University of Central Florida senior and President of her university’s chapter of the conservative group Turning Point USA, took the survey using a link sent to her via text. She encourages every student to participate.

Schiffer said she often feels uncomfortable expressing conservative views on campus and added that she has been flipped off by students for being affiliated with Turning Point USA. During lectures, she said, one of her professors frequently expresses his progressive beliefs.

“There are times when I feel that I cannot talk about the clubs I am involved in or I cannot speak on certain things out of fear of getting failed or having someone be mean or nasty to me,” she said.

Owen Girard, a 19-year-old junior at Florida State University (FSU) and President of his university’s Turning Point USA chapter, said he believes students’ First Amendment rights are at risk with the growing political division on college campuses, making participation in the survey a civic duty.

“You’re an American citizen, first and foremost, and your rights need to be protected,” he said.

Unlike students at the University of Central Florida and the University of Florida, who received the survey through both text and email, Girard received only an email notification. He said he wishes FSU had made more effort to promote the survey, such as by texting students.

Meanwhile, some critics have questioned whether the survey is anonymous as state education officials insist, and expressed doubts about the quality of its methodology.

The lengthy survey also contains an instance in which information is supplied to the student ahead of a question. Before question 49, the survey offers data that purports to be about professors’ alleged party affiliation, saying in part, “A recent national survey of university faculty found that about 56% of professors are Democrat, 16% are Independent, and 27% are Republican.”

No source for the information is provided and the question asks students if they agree or disagree with the statement: “My college or university should take action to promote political diversity among its faculty.” Providing information immediately before a question is a dubious methodological technique that can be used to manipulate polling or survey results. It is known as “push” polling because it pushes the respondent toward a desired answer, rather than simply measuring their opinion.

Michael noted that she believed the 2022 survey was not vetted through an independent review process to determine whether proper precautions had been taken to ensure no personally identifiable information about participants, such as IP addresses, was being collected or stored. It is unclear whether this year’s survey underwent a review process and state officials did not respond to questions about it.

“If it’s going to be anonymous, really make it anonymous” to protect participants from any “negative repercussions,” Michael added.

Cassandra Edwards, a spokesperson for the Board of Governors, said in a statement that the survey is anonymous. She did not respond to efforts to contact her with additional questions.

Stephen Craig, a political science professor at the University of Florida and expert in question writing for survey research, said he was concerned about the lack of answer options on some of the questions about political views and that some could be confusing.

For instance, he cited the question, “Which of the following statements comes closer to your own personal opinion?”

Students could select from only two possible answers: “Speech is violence and should be treated as such by the university” or “It is important for a healthy campus life that the distinctions between speech and violence are maintained.”

“You not only have to write a question that gets at what you’re trying to measure,” he said, “but you need to do it in good conversational language and make it clear as it can be. ‘Speech is violence’ is not clear.”


This story was produced by Fresh Take Florida, a news service of the University of Florida College of Journalism and Communications. The reporters can be reached at [email protected] and [email protected]. You can donate to support our students here.

Fresh Take Florida



    April 16, 2024 at 8:06 pm

    Good evening America,
    I, Earl Pitts American, have already addressed this issue with all of America’s Registared Democrats.
    What basically is going to happen is 73.877% of all registared Democrats, knowing their party’s really “Screwed The Pooch” this time around, are going to “Seceretly Vote Trump” that way they can rejoice that they:
    1.) Saved The Planet from the Sudden Climate Change of WWIII Thermo-Necular Detonation.
    2.) Still enjoy their Blue, Purple, & Green hair Dook 4 Brains Leftist Friends and still engage in disgusting acts of “Leftist” sexual perversions.
    Their “Twisted Freakazoid Friends Will Never Know About Their Sage Trump Vote”.
    America, Earl’s “GOT THIS” and Historically There Has Never Been A Better Time To Relax Your Political Sphincter than right here & now.

    • rick whitaker

      April 17, 2024 at 1:11 pm

      SPHINCTER MAN, your comment is as usual a feeble attempt to be funny and relevant, you failed miserably. you don’t have but a few more months of your childish hope that santa claus is going to bring you a maga president for christmas. you might have another stroke when you are WOKE up to the fact that your world was a dream.

  • Michael K

    April 16, 2024 at 9:28 pm

    Sounds like yet another cut and paste from the Viktor Orban “populist” Authoritarian playbook that attacks colleges and universities, and young people who study there.

  • Old geezer

    April 17, 2024 at 10:10 am

    The best thing these schools can do is advise people to ignore it. That faculty who said “intellectual freedom and diversity isn’t really about political views” nailed it. For us old geezer types, nobody cared or was insulted by what a professor thought or said or not, particularly when you were expected to learn well enough to form and express your own ideas clearly, and if you weren’t ready to do that, fine. You could take it with a grain of salt and make up your own mind later. That’s what intellectual freedom is, not forcing other people to adhere to your own personal views and having the freedom and the mind to make up your mind and also still allow others to do the same. Most of this is not appropriate on a college campus period, unless peers are arguing privately (which used to be fun!) or it pertains to the class. It’s stupid but it’s also really damaging. You know with the skewed responses they get (only the screechy wheels) they can use it to hurt the schools again. Everybody’s always looking for the insult and the injury these days trying to out victim one another and it’s so defeating. Florida brain power is circling the drain.

    • Speedy Gonzalez

      April 17, 2024 at 6:45 pm

      Thank you Old Geez for your total agreement with MY, Earl Pitts American’s above words of Sage Wisdom.
      Welcome Geez to The Earl Pitts American Fan Club and Thank You For Your Service Sir.
      Earl Pitts American

      • Speedy Gonzalez

        April 17, 2024 at 6:47 pm

        Woops America,
        I was over at Speedy and SloPokes camp and accidently picked up Speedy’s phone and posted on it.
        My Bad,

        • rick whitaker

          April 18, 2024 at 9:32 pm

          EARL, you punk, this hispanic racism is over the top. someone is going to give your house address out to the hispanic community with copies of your racist posts. is that what you are hoping for .

  • rick whitaker

    April 17, 2024 at 1:43 pm

    this survey is MUCH worse than i had thought. now since this article filled it in for me i am even more confident that desantis needs lawsuits filed against him.

  • Jojo

    April 18, 2024 at 7:36 am

    Does this strike anyone else as Big Brother Watching?
    DeSantes is a want to be autocrat

  • KathrynA

    April 20, 2024 at 2:36 pm

    Yes, it does and also, sounds like the indoctrination of German young people in Nazi Germany. I’m so glad my grandchildren have just now graduated from Florida Universities!

  • Dont Say FLA

    April 23, 2024 at 3:28 pm

    Nobody’s vote alienates anyone else unless they blab, in which case it’s probably their blabbing and likely shaming friends who voted differently that alienates folks.

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704