Guest Author
Recent discussions over the future of asphalt shingles in Florida have sparked unnecessary confusion among homeowners. Some special interest groups — many of which sell competing roofing products — have attempted to misrepresent asphalt shingles as a less effective or outdated choice. Their goal? To push their alternative materials, which are significantly more expensive for consumers, all while capitalizing on broad statements made by Florida’s Insurance Commissioner.
Let’s set the record straight. Asphalt shingles are the most widely used residential roofing material in Florida, covering 70–75% of homes statewide, so of course, they show up more often in reports of damage. If a major storm hits, it’s a matter of simple math — more asphalt shingle roofs will be affected because they are the predominant choice. But that doesn’t mean they’re failing at a higher rate than other materials. In fact, many asphalt roofs withstand severe weather just as well as other options, if not better, when properly installed.
Some in Tallahassee are pushing to restrict the use of asphalt shingles. But the real issue facing Florida’s roofing market isn’t those shingles — it’s the quality of installation, evolving building codes and aging infrastructure. Many roofs that failed during storms were installed before today’s stricter building codes, while others were put on by unqualified contractors rushing through post-storm rebuilds. No roofing material is immune to poor installation or age-related wear.
Additionally, different roofing materials serve different needs. The best option for each homeowner depends on their budget, home structure and climate considerations. Forcing Floridians toward more costly alternatives, like metal or tile, could price many families out of safe, reliable housing.
Asphalt shingle technology has evolved significantly in recent decades. Today, high-performance laminated shingles make up 90% of Florida’s asphalt roofing market, incorporating advancements in wind resistance, waterproofing, and fire protection. The asphalt roofing industry continues to work alongside contractors and building code officials to improve product performance further.
For example, the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association has proposed a series of Florida Building Code improvements, including enhancements to hip and ridge shingle wind resistance and better attachment at roof edges. Many manufacturers are also working to strengthen national product standards, ensuring that asphalt shingles remain at the forefront of roofing technology.
Asphalt shingles are the leading roofing choice in North America for a reason: They’re cost-effective, durable and aesthetically versatile. Calls to restrict or discourage their use in Florida ignore both the realities of the roofing industry and the financial burden such policies would place on homeowners. Public policy should focus on improving roofing standards across the board — not unfairly steering consumers toward costly alternatives.
Florida homeowners deserve accurate information, not fear tactics. Asphalt shingles remain a proven, high-performance roofing solution and will continue to be a steadfast choice for families across the state.
___
Reed Hitchcock is the executive vice president of the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association.
