Dan Markel trial: Katherine Magbanua gets life + 60 years; Charlie Adelson trial early 2023; Tara Kawass opens up
Katherine Magbanua's retrial starts with a civics lesson. Image via WFSU.

Magbanua WFSU
For the Markel family, today is one more brick in the long road toward justice.

“13 years ago today, Dan Markel became a dad,” read an early morning Facebook post by Justice for Dan, marking the birthday of Markel’s oldest son. But today brought more than a coming-of-age celebration for the son and family of the slain FSU law professor.

Today, two conspirators in Markel’s murder appeared in front of Judge Robert Wheeler: Katherine Magbanua, for sentencing in her first-degree murder conviction, and Charlie Adelson, for a case management hearing. He has been charged with the same.

The hearings were somber and short.

Outside of the courtroom, case-watchers waited in the dark, hoping to hear news of Magbanua’s cooperation — which, if she had done so, could have expedited arrests of other named co-conspirators in the case, such as Wendi Adelson, Markel’s ex-wife, and her mother Donna Adelson, or could have generated more evidence against Charlie Adelson, who has been arrested already.

But cooperation — if it happened — was not apparent.

“Magbanua was sentenced to the maximum allowed under law — life with no possibility of parole, followed by two consecutive 30 year sentences for conspiracy and solicitation,” shared Karen Cyphers with Justice for Dan, who was present for the hearing.

Magbanua’s lawyer, Tara Kawass, had asked for these two sentences to run concurrently — but Wheeler rejected this symbolic effort.

For the Markel family, today is one more brick in the long road toward justice.

Dan’s sister Shelly Markel read a victim impact statement over Zoom, sharing the pain and grief her family has endured since 2014. Her words were poignant and biting — a big sister who had once guided her little brother through life’s early milestones, before the two became close confidants, sharing things large and small. A brilliant mind, gone, and a loving brother, son, and father, forever ripped from those who loved him and needed him.

Shelly spoke of recognizing Dan’s mischievousness and confidence in her own son’s eyes and smile and agonized over whether Dan’s two children would ever come to know what traits they share with their father.

Even Kawass, who spoke on behalf Magbanua, underscored these sentiments. Kawass expressed Magbanua’s sympathy for the Markel family’s loss and shared her client’s sadness for the alienation the Markels have endured, being separated from his two sons. Wendi cut ties immediately after members of the Adelson family were publicly implicated in his killing, and only began reestablishing contact after the ‘Markel Act’ was passed by the Florida Legislature in 2022.

“My life as a grandmother was yanked away from me,” Ruth Markel wrote in her victim impact statement. “Other lives were destroyed as well. Benjamin and Lincoln have forever been deprived of a relationship with their father, and will grow up and go through life without a father.”

Benjamin’s milestone bar mitzvah came and went in May with no members of their father’s family present in person or via livestream — that invitation was revoked after Charlie’s arrest, despite other guests still welcome to celebrate. All the while, the boys’ other grandmother, Donna, was present in the synagogue: the same grandmother who had accused Dan of being a “religious zealot” for his commitment to Jewish tradition; who had suggested Wendi threaten to convert the boys to Catholicism if Dan didn’t let them move to Miami; and who had floated the idea of dressing the boys in Hitler Youth costumes to make a bigger statement.

While Dan’s boys were not in the courtroom, their presence, and their tragedy, was surely felt by all. After Wheeler read Magbanua’s sentence, Kawass asked the court to appoint a public defender to handle any possible appeals, and Magbanua was escorted back to jail.

Charlie’s case management hearing followed. In this, his lawyer Daniel Rashbaum repeated to the court his client’s request for an Arthur Hearing — an attempt to secure bail and pretrial release for his client. Wheeler said that the hearing will be scheduled within 30 to 60 days, anticipated to take half of a day. But if Magbanua was repeatedly denied bail, including by Wheeler, it’s most likely Charlie will be denied, too.

One of Rashbaum’s main arguments for bail is that Charlie never fled after being named as a suspect in this case. However, Charlie was captured on multiple wiretapped recordings talking about doing so.

“If they had any evidence, we would have already gone to the airport,” he had said to Magbanua in 2016, the day after the FBI bump in which Donna was approached by an undercover agent disguised as a blackmailer. Charlie had gone so far as to look into charter plane arrangements, too. Ultimately, the decision lies with Wheeler.

Charlie’s next case management hearing will be set for November or December, and a trial could happen as soon as January 2023. Cappleman requested Adelson’s trial be scheduled for a full three weeks.

Following the hearings, Kawass stood for an hour with media, talking about the case and what’s to come. She said that while Magbanua will have a public defender for any possible appeals, she and her co-counsel Christopher DeCoste remain by her side.

Kawass suggested reporters look into a small piece of evidence tucked into the testimony of Shoddrick Nobles, a man who met Sigfredo Garcia and Luis Rivera and sold them drugs on their trips to Tallahassee. During one trip, the hitmen had car trouble, and Nobles attested that the duo considered calling a woman who lived in Tallahassee for help.

“It couldn’t have been Katie,” Kawass said. “She was in Miami.”

Kawass emphasized her desire for Garcia to cooperate, in order to bring the other parties to justice. Kawass is confident that Garcia could do so, and expressed that if Magbanua were to finally confess her role and provide additional information, she would support that decision fully.

But if and until then, a new wait begins.

Peter Schorsch

Peter Schorsch is the President of Extensive Enterprises Media and is the publisher of FloridaPolitics.com, INFLUENCE Magazine, and Sunburn, the morning read of what’s hot in Florida politics. Previous to his publishing efforts, Peter was a political consultant to dozens of congressional and state campaigns, as well as several of the state’s largest governmental affairs and public relations firms. Peter lives in St. Petersburg with his wife, Michelle, and their daughter, Ella.


4 comments

  • Rob Petrie

    July 29, 2022 at 1:49 pm

    If you followed the Markel case you have learned the perfect example of how justice works in a leftist run Florida County. The County of jurisdiction is 100% leftist run from State Attorney Campbell down to their Dog Catcher.
    Had Markel been a non white minority and the crime been one of the way too many black on black shootings in any leftist run Florida Coumty the case would have been shut down quickly with a one time blurb in local media.
    Leftist justice liberal white folks style is quite different you know.

  • Jeannie

    July 29, 2022 at 2:18 pm

    I never saw this woman she’d a tear until the verdict was read. I’m not sure that she was crying.

  • A B

    July 30, 2022 at 10:09 am

    Imagine the atonement prayers Donna attempts when she’s in the synagogue on Yom Kippur…

  • Swamp frog

    July 31, 2022 at 11:21 am

    I am not sure how fair this system is towards the children of both families. Garcia’s and Magbanua’s children now have neither dad nor mom. So Dan Markel kept his trophy-wife in home-prison, enjoying his career and travelling, while his not less-educated and accomplished wife was taking care of little kids and dreamed of leaving Tallahassee. To console herself she wrote a novel, which he did not even bother reading. So she left, and upon realizing he couldn’t take her back, he started to revenge on her, taking 50/50 custody on little kids, forcing her in his Tallahassee-prison (who could even argue that Miami would be better for kids), and attempting to limit her mother’s help (who was driving to Miami every other week!) with kids. Does it really sound what a good dad or good person would do? Now, of course it does not justify them murdering him (which was not 100% proven), but totally justifies them hating him (which is the basis of the charges). But does it really make things better to deprive other two children from both their parents, and likely deprive Markel’s sons of their mother who clearly took care of them well and the family who has been raising them? Do Dan Markel’s parents really love their grandchildren that in order to get “justice” their want such fate for them? Could there be some other form of punishment that wouldn’t make innocent children of both families become, essentially, victims of all this mess?

Comments are closed.


#FlaPol

Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Renzo Downey, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Kelly Hayes, Joe Henderson, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Scott Powers, Gray Rohrer, Aimee Sachs, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Andrew Wilson, Wes Wolfe, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704




Sign up for Sunburn


Categories