Janelle Irwin Taylor
A proposed resolution from Pinellas County Commissioner Vince Nowicki that would have banned displays in the Palm Harbor Library depicting topics related to sexual identity and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) principles has been tabled.
During a new business discussion at its regular board meeting, Pinellas County Commissioners considered whether the board should assert its authority over the library to ensure “a family-focused environment that is free from any form of sexual identity promotion or discussion in the children’s section.”
Several Commissioners, including Chair Brian Scott and Commissioners Chris Latvala and Dave Eggers, suggested giving the library advisory board and other leaders time to assuage concerns about recent displays spotlighting LGBTQ+ issues, though they agreed with the resolution’s sentiment.
As a result, no action was taken, but the proposed resolution prompted concerns from the LGBTQ+ community and its allies that the board was attempting to remove items related to LGBTQ+ issues and content deemed related to DEI initiatives and theories.
Nowicki described such fears as “misinformation” and claimed pushback was coming from outside the Palm Harbor community. He further argued that his resolution didn’t call for books to be banned or removed, but rather addressed displays and brochures.
His resolution included six actionable items, including the prohibition of “the active promotion or endorsement of sexual identity in the children’s section.” That item specifically listed “visual displays, posters, or artwork that reference or depict any themes related to sexual identity,” as well as “oral presentations, storytelling events, or programs that include references to sexual identity.” It also specifically would have banned pamphlets, brochures or handouts that promote sexual identity.
The resolution also directly stated that books referencing sexual identity “shall not be restricted from the library’s collection,” but that such items “shall not be highlighted, featured, or actively promoted through displays, programs, or other means.”
It further called for regular audits of displays and programs within the children’s section of the library and for the immediate removal of any noncompliant materials or displays, as well as accountability measures for staff who violate policy.
Additionally, the resolution called for “clear signage” in the children’s section outlining policy, and a strategic plan within 120 days of adoption. The resolution called for a strategic plan “free of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) principles, content, language, or policies.”
The issue came up after Nowicki learned of a display at Palm Harbor Library authors in the LGBTQ+ community with a sign showing a rainbow heart saying “everyone is welcome here.” The display also included a Lego set entitled “Everyone is Awesome” and a brochure with lists of LGBTQ+ books.
Library staff has since removed the display. Library Director Matthew David told Nowicki that his staff would remove “sexual identity” stickers from books after Nowicki expressed concerns about such stickers possibly embarrassing parents who pulled the book from the shelf. While David agreed to remove the stickers, he also explained that they were not just to identify books with a particular topic, but to inform parents who may wish to avoid such content for their children.
This isn’t the first time the Palm Harbor Library has been targeted over LGBTQ+ displays. Latvala two years ago expressed concern about a Pride display in the children’s section, which was ultimately removed after pushback.
Now, Commissioners are leaving it to the Palm Harbor Community Services Agency (PHCSA), which oversees the library, to ensure age-appropriate content that aligns with Commission priorities.
One comment
Deplorable Pinellas
March 26, 2025 at 6:14 am
At least one commissioner had a backbone to stand by his campaign. Can’t say much for the others. Latvala is probably the most disappointing out of the 7.