Alan Grayson addresses ‘The Great American Bathroom Controversy,’ rips Republicans, North Carolina

Alan Grayson and cisgender

Democratic U.S. Rep. Alan Grayson of Orlando ripped North Carolina lawmakers and Republicans on the floor of Congress Friday declaring that state’s transgender restroom law “stupid,” and rhetorically asking, “Are you nuts?”

Grayson, in a 13-minute speech given during the House of Representative’s open floor time, offered support of transgendered people being able to use the restrooms of their gender identities. He said it would be ridiculous to force someone who identifies as, dresses as, looks like and acts like a woman to use a men’s room.

Grayson is running for the U.S. Senate in Florida and has a tough Democratic primary fight with U.S. Rep. Patrick Murphy of Jupiter and Pam Keith of Palm Beach Gardens.

In his speech his target was the Republican Party, whom he blamed for North Carolina’s law, House Bill 2, and for other laws and regulations like it, such as the Marion County School District’s new restroom rules, though he did not mention the others specifically.

He accused North Carolina lawmakers of being “bigots.”

He accused the Republican Party of trying to put government “under the toilet seat.”

“Are you nuts?” he asked. “Listen, I have heard that the Republican Party is the party of small government. I’ve also heard that on the issue of abortion, the party of small government wants government small enough to fit into a woman’s uterus. Now it turns out, the party of small government wants government small enough to fit under the toilet seat.

“Can’t we all be adults about this?” Grayson continued. “Do we really need a new law on this subject, much less a stupid law, a bad law, a ridiculous law?”

He said the effect of the North Carolina law would be, “People who self-identify as women, people who look like women, people who act like women, they somehow are being driven into the men’s room. And the same thing is true with transgendered people who identify as men .… You’re going to force them into the ladies’ room.

“My God! What’s wrong with you?” he declared. “That doesn’t make any sense at all.”

Grayson compared the transgender restroom issue with pre-Civil Rights movement Jim Crow restroom laws that required separate restrooms for whites and blacks.

Along the way, according to Towleroad.com, a gay news and entertainment website, Grayson became the first member of Congress to use the word “cisgender,” which refers to people who identify with the gender they were born with.

“People who are cisgendered have no right to dictate where people who are transgendered urinate, any more than people who are white have the right to dictate where people who are black do it,” he said. “That’s not America. Let’s show some common sense.”

And he brought props. Grayson started out with a poster picture of Christine Jorgensen, the first famous transgendered person in America. She was a former male World War II soldier who, in the early 1950s, had transgender surgery and therapy in Denmark to become female, and then lived out her life open about it in the United States. Grayson spoke of her in heroic terms and said as far as he knew no one ever asked or cared where she went to the bathroom.

“Now thanks to Republicans, bigots in North Carolina, we have a new law that would require Christine Jorgensen to go to the men’s room. Think about that. Think about that. In fact, the natural consequence of that law is what I’m about to show you right here.

He flipped the picture to show the next: stock art of two young women standing at urinals.

“That,” Grayson said.

Scott Powers

Scott Powers is an Orlando-based political journalist with 30+ years’ experience, mostly at newspapers such as the Orlando Sentinel and the Columbus Dispatch. He covers local, state and federal politics and space news across much of Central Florida. His career earned numerous journalism awards for stories ranging from the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster to presidential elections to misplaced nuclear waste. He and his wife Connie have three grown children. Besides them, he’s into mystery and suspense books and movies, rock, blues, basketball, baseball, writing unpublished novels, and being amused. Email him at [email protected].


One comment

  • John Mayor

    May 14, 2016 at 8:51 pm

    THE GAY/ LESBIAN AGENDA FREQUENTLY POSES AS A TRANSGENDERED AGENDA (and… the Gay/ Lesbian Agenda, and the Transgendered Agenda, not to be confused with the “Gay/ Lesbian Transexual Agenda”, and the “Gay/ Lesbian Transexual Gender Re-assignment Surgery Agenda”!… which are other matters, altogether!)!
    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    ALL GAYS/ LESBIANS WERE NOT SIMPLY “BORN THAT WAY”!… AND!… JUST AS ALL TRANSEXUALS WERE NOT “BORN THAT WAY”!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    Such thinking, would suggest that there’s no such thing as “FREE WILL”/ “CHOICE” when it comes to sexual orientation (the TRULY TRANSGENDERED, being the exception to this!)! And again!… not to be confused with those who are merely transexual!… or!… transexuals who have “CHOSEN” “Gender Re-assignment Surgery”!… and!… DESPITE EVIDENCE OF ANY PROVEN BIOLOGICAL/ GENETIC PREDISPOSITION TO BEING “BORN THAT WAY”, AND POSSESSING A TRULY “TRANSGENDERED BIO-SEXUAL ORIENTATION”!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    THE RATIONALE FOR “TRANSGENDERED GENDER RE-ASSIGNMENT SURGERY” IS NOT SYNONYMOUS!… AND IS NOT TO BE MADE SYNONYMOUS!… WITH “GAY/ LESBIAN TRANSEXUAL GENDER RE-ASSIGNMENT SURGERY”!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    For!… it’s one thing for a six year old boy to want to cut off his genitals due to an overwhelming biological (hormonal) predisposition to femininity!… but!… it’s quite another issue, to do so, based on a series of “familially-based, peer-based, or socially-based behavioral influences (and!… on many occasions!… due to incidents of ‘incest-based, peer-based, or stranger-based SEXUAL ABUSE’!– whether as children, and/ or, as adults!)”!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    So… the question, is:… are you “coming out” to reveal your gay/ lesbian “CHOICE” OF ORIENTATION (i.e., a “CHOICE” based on whatever “NURTURE-BASED/ non-biological” circumstances may have led you to your resolve!)!… or!… are you anxious to end the REAL MENTAL/ EMOTIONAL PAIN of hiding a TRULY “BIOLOGICALLY-BASED CONDITION” THAT YOU HAVE HAD– HAVE!– NO CONTROL OVER (AND WHICH MAY HAVE LED YOU– IS LEADING YOU!– TO THE POINT OF SELF-HARM!… OR!– WORSE!… SUICIDE!)?

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    If it’s the former… fine!… THAT’S YOUR “CHOICE”!… BUT (and… if it was your “FREE CHOICE”!), DON’T THEN, HAVE YOURSELF– AND/ OR US!– BELIEVE, THAT YOUR DECISION TO COME FORWARD WAS BASED ON SOME BIOLOGICAL/ GENETIC PRECONDITION THAT “PREEMPTED” YOUR “TRUE DECISIONMAKING (I.E., THAT YOU WERE ‘BORN THAT WAY’!… OR HAD NO ‘FREE CHOICE’ IN THE MATTER!)”! AND!… IF YOUR “WOULD-BE CHOICE” WAS “PREEMPTED” BY WAY OF SOMEONE ELSE’S MANIPULATION OF YOUR “FREE WILL (E.G., BY WAY OF AN ABUSER!)”!… AND, YOU’VE SUFFERED– AND/ OR ARE SUFFERING!– MENTAL/ EMOTIONAL PAIN AS A RESULT OF SOMEONE ELSE’S PAST– AND/ OR PRESENT!– MANIPULATION OF YOUR OTHERWISE “FREE WILL”!… THAT MANIPULATION DOES NOT EQUATE TO BEING “BORN THAT WAY”! AND SO!… AND AS SUCH!… YOU MUST BEGIN TO SORT OUT– HONESTLY!– WHAT HAS HAPPENED (AND/ OR IS HAPPENING!) TO YOU!… AND TO SEEK TO EITHER ACCEPT A TRULY “TRANSGENDERED STATE”!… OR!… SEEK TO ESTABLISH WHETHER YOUR “WILL” IN YOUR SEXUAL ORIENTATION, WAS “PREEMPTED”– AND/ OR IS BEING “PREEMPTED”!– BY ANOTHER, OR OTHERS!… OR NOT!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    As for “BATHROOM LAWS”!… a “THIRD BATHROOM”!– AND DESPITE THE COSTS, AND DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS!– would be a wiser solution, than pitting hetero males and females (adults, or children!) against the transgendered, and/ or gays, or lesbians! And to offset the costs for “The Third Bathroom (an excellent title for a movie… starring whoever! And wherein!… a gay, and lesbian meet– and fall in love!)”, I’d suggest, Crowdfunding campaigns!… and/ or!… the proceeds, from a movie!

    ___________________

    NEW PARA/ SPACE

    ___________________

    Please!… no emails!

Comments are closed.


#FlaPol

Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Jesse Scheckner, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704