Florida League of Cities to Ron DeSantis: Veto cancer benefits for firefighters

firefighter weekend
The League called it a "significant unfunded mandate."

The Florida League of Cities sent a letter to Gov. Ron DeSantis asking him to veto a bill mandating cancer coverage for firefighters across the state.

That brought immediate outrage from Republican Chief Financial Officer and State Fire Marshal Jimmy Patronis, who supports the legislation, calling the league’s position “shameful.”

The League has consistently opposed the legislation, arguing it unfairly shifts costs to local governments.

The legislation (SB 426) was recently approved by both chambers of the Legislature, the local governments that employ the firefighters are responsible for paying for the costs of coverage.

The measure is what’s called a “presumptive cancer law.” That means should a firefighter in good health get one of 21 identified types of cancer, it is presumed the cancer stemmed from his or her work as a firefighter.

Cancer treatment itself is often already covered by existing health plans. But firefighters can often foot the bill for out-of-pocket expenses such as co-pays and deductibles.

The newly-passed measure would require those expenses to be covered in an effort to ensure firefighters don’t have to go through an arduous workers’ compensation process to prove those cancers stemmed from their employment.

Amber Hughes testified on behalf of the League at multiple committees, opposing the bill.

“At the end of the day, (local governments) do have to set millage rates and set appropriate local tax rates that can fund these benefits,” Hughes said during one hearing before the Senate Community Affairs Committee.

“And it’s going to be quite difficult to develop a budget and develop these appropriate tax levels without having any idea of the fiscal impact.”

Those concerns were echoed in the letter sent to the Governor Monday.

“In theory, it sounds like a worthwhile initiative, which is why it was met with great fanfare during Legislative Session. However, when you dig into the details, this is a significant unfunded mandate with widespread negative impact on property taxpayers,” the letter reads.

“The bill should be vetoed because it is grossly unresearched, and its unknown financial implications are disruptive if not disastrous ton Florida taxpayers.”

The letter also raises concerns that volunteer firefighters would be hurt.

According to the bill, firefighters only qualify for the cancer presumption if he or she “has not been employed in any other position in the preceding 5 years which is proven to create a higher risk for any cancer” (emphasis added).

Representatives from the League argue that provision will dissuade firefighters from volunteering elsewhere, as that “other position” as a volunteer could disqualify them from those cancer benefits.

The bill’s proponents have countered concerns from local governments, arguing that doing nothing would hurt cities far more than any costs associated with the bill.

Not covering these extra costs, they argue, could cause a sharp drop in people applying to be firefighters.

“Seventy percent of firefighter line-of-duty deaths are cancer related and the men and women fighting this disease need to know that Florida stands with them,” Patronis said after the Senate approved the bill.

On Twitter, Patronis blasted the League’s calls for a veto.

“The is at it again — more attacks against doing the RIGHT thing for our firefighters,” Patronis tweeted. “It’s SHAMEFUL.”

Patronis later added a lengthier statement further blasting the Florida League.

“It’s shameful that the Florida League of Cities is pressuring Gov. DeSantis to veto a great bill which will ensure our firefighters receive the cancer coverage they need and deserve,” Patronis said.

“Nationwide, 70 percent of firefighter line-of-duty deaths in 2016 were cancer-related—firefighters are dying from cancer at higher rates than you or me. It seems that Florida League of Cities, once again, does not care about these heartbreaking statistics or the brave men and women who they represent.

“Excuses for not wanting to step up and putting politics in front of our firefighters is shameful. Last year, the Florida League of Cities challenged our fight for important PTSD benefits for first responders, and now they oppose ways to help firefighters fight cancer. The League of Cities continues to show they don’t care about the first responders who protect their communities every day.”

Ryan Nicol

Ryan Nicol covers news out of South Florida for Florida Politics. Ryan is a native Floridian who attended undergrad at Nova Southeastern University before moving on to law school at Florida State. After graduating with a law degree he moved into the news industry, working in TV News as a writer and producer, along with some freelance writing work. If you'd like to contact him, send an email to [email protected].


  • Cherie

    May 1, 2019 at 4:10 pm

    Any other job with a higher risk… So for example don’t volunteer at a chemical manufacturing plant. If they want an idea of how much it costs, check with other local government bodies who do take responsibility for the harm caused by exposure to multiple known carcinogens on a regular basis as part of their job helping others. Cut waste and red tape, not this type of cover. Per citizen, given it is mostly overflow costs, sounds like it would cost a fraction of a percent on the rates.

  • play8oy install

    May 11, 2019 at 2:09 pm

    Online casinos indeed produced great spot for people who wanted to pay their
    spare time more innovative. And perhaps quantity the
    factors why this recreational activity becomes really in-demand is the its chance to offer you with superb casino
    games, bonuses, and tournaments. Well it holds true that nearly all online casino games have their own own as well as strategies when it comes
    to winning. Even though of them were purely based on luck, dealing not indicate that
    item . make utilization of any tips which will help you increase your odds.
    Continue reading below and learn a few general strategies for your online
    casino game.

    Be very knowledgeable for the games an individual playing.
    Considerably more no better way to win a game than to keep the power of
    knowledge. You do not enter a battle unarmed right?
    So in playing online casinos, you must come light and portable best weapon–the knowhow.
    Be diligent to find out the rules of online game.

    Analyze exactly what the concept will then be observe the
    people playing as well as the they interact with
    each other. Learn about guidelines and really understand these individuals.
    Lastly, look at the odds that match your bet on choice and
    compare it with other malaysia slot. It so happens that some casino games have a
    higher payout using a lower house edge. Know which is which and select the right game
    for you, which often boils down to which games will win you more money.

    Before start your journey in playing slot online, it extremely important for one to understand the guidance in playing keep in mind this.
    When you try to play it without understanding the essential rule and trick in playing it, you will loose your useless.
    Purpose of playing slot is collecting your victory. Mafia wars will give you a
    associated with some images base on the roll of images.
    When the roll stop and along with the same image, undertake it !
    win it.

    If the huge paying places on budget friendly of both lists win, a lot of people is actually going to received 101 and 200 to 1
    likelihood – a killer top prize by any standard! 2 odds makers believe on the prime two likely frontrunners (Sweden and Russia), but the
    resemblance end there.

    Perhaps one of the most prevalent roulette myth
    quantity of encounter could be the assumption that the
    majority of roulette wheels will appear the aforesaid.
    The thing is, even if all roulette tables were developed by the same company, every wheel to get independent for this others.
    Which means that even if you’re spot a pattern on a particular table, it is quite unlikely that might be the same in the adjacent one.

    As all casino players would know, following this myths can be quite
    very frustrating on the end, not to mention being totally damaging to your wallet.
    Knowing these myths can help you in avoiding them.

    You would get more enhanced odds of winning if the casino you’re playing in offers a rule called
    the en prison bet. Operates on lessens household edge one.35%, which is very acceptable
    truly. This rule only is applicable to even money bets,
    however. Let’s say you’ve got a bet on dark-coloured. If the ball lands on a
    zero slot, your bet does not win or lose, but is locked up for another spin. Should the ball
    hits black for your next spin, you buy original bet. If it lands on red, you lose.
    And in case the ball lands on yet another zero, your bet is imprisoned 1 more brown. http://parohodov.com/index/away?url=http://www.88xxw.com/comment/html/?74175.html

  • live22 demo id

    May 12, 2019 at 8:57 am

    Football is a well loved sport that gets people involved.
    The game is high action and fast paced with star athletes in the industry
    on the area. They are able using their feet and visit move the ball but not their hands other compared goalie.

    The idea of the game is to get your football into the goal of this opposing team.
    Of course they are for you to do all they can to prevent that from happening.

    The idea is this; you may hear concerning how people are watching television on the online world or with regard to specific, watch live sports TV on the.

    Well, millions of viewers worldwide in fact hiding their own rooms and enjoying
    a proper live American football game in in 2011 or tuning into other sports channels.
    And they are eager to do so with PC satellite TV software.

    Want phones that aren’t Android-based an individual can have your Windows items on it?

    Windows phones are for you, then. A number of these is the Nokia Lumia 928 with image stabilization, great for photos and video too as the Samsung ATIV Odyssey features an in order to use Windows
    8 format. Lastly, the HTC Trophy can play register live22 and Zune photographs.

    ITunes Simply because this service is owned by Apple, made on the iPad from found.
    It provides wide collection of TV programs,
    in both high meaning and typical definition. Several shows are present,
    available just day-to-day or so after ventilation on cable
    and show networks.

    When you play online, will knowing poker tells be insightful?

    Of course. Poker tells will differ slightly from player to player, however your
    online opponents are still humans. Tips to observe closely
    is time or duration that a rival spends throughout his
    turn or chance to bet.

    Aside from actual win rate, each form of poker has some advantages.
    Live poker can be a much more social video. If you’re a social person and in the market for
    out and interact with normal folks and a few fun, you can like
    live poker more. The internet however allows you play poker in your underwear (or whatever).
    Can easily play at any moment and don’t even should leave the home.
    This convenience appeals to a lot of people.
    A spot . whether poker on-line or going to the casino suits you, you must keep from heart why you play poker on-line.
    If you play for entertainment or a social experience, than live
    action could be the way to go to. If you are strictly business, as compared
    to rakeback, poker games bonuses, multitabling, and large
    amount of volume of hands, you will definitely do
    better with texas hold’em.

    It provides extensive of connectivity options, to tell you the truth- I do not need these guys.
    They are plenty for our company. The sound quality is also top class; the screen is made
    from 1366 x 768 pixels and its contrast ratio 5500:1.

    This software has over 3,000 channels from
    everywhere. This includes movies, music, live games, educational shows, cartoons at the same time the news.

    That means each person can get some benefit from satellite TV on PC software.

    Where can come across this software so undertake it !
    watch satellite tv online at no cost? It can be seen on many retailers
    internet. How long does it take? From downloading to installing to
    getting the software, it takes no about an hour for a
    computer illiterate particular. http://sildenafilcitratecom.com/22213liverunningstatus8620

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn