Matt Gaetz and far right feuded with Kevin McCarthy for weeks. Here’s how it’s spiraling into a shutdown.
Matt Gaetz and Lauren Boebert. Image via AP.

Gaetz Boebert
Will McCarthy need Democrats to break an impasse? And will that cost him his gavel?

With little time left to prevent a government shutdown, the House is in a familiar position: effectively paralyzed as conservatives feud with Speaker Kevin McCarthy over matters large and small.

McCarthy has pushed the Republican conference to embrace a short-term funding plan that would include a sweeping Republican proposal for the southern border. But a small group of hard-line conservatives has defied the Speaker in a quest to get rid of stopgap funding plans, known as continuing resolutions, even if opposing them means forcing a government shutdown.

It’s left McCarthy at an impasse. The California Congressman will likely be left with the political damage of a shutdown unless he turns to Democrats for help in passing a bipartisan bill. But working with Democrats would give hard-right Republicans reason to remove him as Speaker.

Here’s what to know about the House Republicans’ conflict and where it may be headed:

What are they fighting over?

At its core, the conflict is over how far to the right House Republicans should push legislation — and what level of compromise, if any, is acceptable.

Pragmatic-minded Republicans acknowledge they hold just one chamber of Congress and must negotiate legislation with a Democratic President and the Democratic-held Senate. But some conservatives, organized around the House Freedom Caucus — as well as the score of Republicans who opposed McCarthy’s bid to become Speaker — have taken combative stands as they try to disrupt business as usual in Washington.

They are determined to not only slash spending levels but remake the U.S. government, which they view with growing enmity and criticize as “woke and weaponized.” Some conservatives have downplayed the effects of a government shutdown and even contend that it would have benefits.

“The Biden regulatory agenda comes to a grinding halt with a government shutdown,” Russell Vought, an influential strategist among the right-wing lawmakers, posted on social media this week.

In the current clash over funding the government, the debate has centered on whether Congress should use stopgap funding legislation to keep government offices running and paychecks for federal employees flowing beyond Friday, when the government’s fiscal year expires.

What is McCarthy doing?

McCarthy is urging his fellow House Republicans to avoid the political pain of causing a shutdown as he tries to protect his narrow House majority. But because Republicans had such a slim majority to begin with, even a handful of holdouts can demand concessions or prevent the party from moving forward on legislation.

In his eight months as Speaker, McCarthy has at times surprised Washington with his ability to maneuver with his fragile majority. But now that he is facing a government shutdown, he is caught between commitments he made during the two major crises Congress faced this year: the fight over choosing a House Speaker and negotiations to suspend the nation’s debt limit.

McCarthy had to win support from almost every House Republican in his grueling bid to become Speaker in January. To do so, he made a range of concessions, including an agreement to cut government spending to certain levels and pass each of the 12 annual appropriations bills individually.

Then in June, as he negotiated with President Joe Biden to suspend the nation’s debt limit, McCarthy agreed to hold the government’s annual discretionary funding to $1.59 trillion. That deal passed the House, in part due to support from Democrats.

“He’s made promises to part of the conference with the deal that he cut with President Biden on certain numbers,” said Republican Rep. Ken Buck, who is part of the House Freedom Caucus. “Then he’s made promises to get elected Speaker to a different part of the conference. And those two numbers are pretty far apart.”

McCarthy’s allies have insisted the Speaker has kept his word and is still fighting for the spending levels he promised Republicans in January.

Who are the other key players?

Rep. Matt Gaetz, a bombastic conservative and close ally to former President Donald Trump, has emerged as the chief foil to McCarthy. The Florida Republican rallied GOP lawmakers to resist McCarthy’s bid to become Speaker in January and is now openly threatening a bid to remove him from the office.

At a closed-door GOP meeting on Thursday, Gaetz confronted McCarthy and asked whether he was involved in a campaign of conservative internet influencers posting negative things about him. The Speaker retorted that he would not waste time on something like that, according to Gaetz.

Gaetz’s tactics prompted profanity-laced derision from Rep. French Hill, a close McCarthy ally.

McCarthy has tried to call Gaetz’s bluff and dared him to move on his threats. But for now, Gaetz is mostly focused on rallying Republicans, such as Reps. Andy Ogles of Tennessee, Anna Paulina Luna of Florida and Eli Crane of Arizona, to stand firm in opposing any temporary funding bill.

As House Republicans scrambled to find a path forward this week, Rep. Matt Rosendale, a Republican fiscal hard-liner, blasted GOP leadership for failing to bring up spending bills for House votes long before the end of the fiscal year.

“This is an incredible failure on the part of leadership by not starting this process back in June, July, when we would have had ample time to get through it all,” he said.

McCarthy has pointed the finger back at Gaetz and the conservatives, saying work on the appropriations bills was delayed all summer and into the fall due to their demands.

“When they stop the bills from coming up, and if he votes against a continuing resolution, it’s my fault? That’s interesting,” McCarthy said.

In the background, Trump has also urged the hard-line conservatives to hold out for sweeping concessions even if a shutdown is needed.

Biden, meanwhile, has avoided the fight in Congress besides repeatedly blaming House Republicans for the dysfunction. He has called on McCarthy to enforce the spending levels agreed to in the debt limit deal.

McCarthy has tried to drag Biden into the debate, calling on him to meet with Republicans to discuss the border security proposals that the Speaker wants to attach to the temporary funding legislation.

How will the standoff end?

A government shutdown is almost inevitable at this point. But the duration of the shutdown, as well as the future of McCarthy’s speakership, is impossible to predict.

For now, McCarthy is still searching for support from his own party, hoping he can leverage his thin majority to force negotiations with Democrats. But the Senate is working on a temporary, bipartisan funding plan that is likely to pass in the coming days, adding more pressure on McCarthy to work with Democrats to avert a shutdown.

If McCarthy works with Democrats, Gaetz has promised he’ll try to oust McCarthy by filing a so-called “motion to vacate the chair.” Procedural votes could be offered to halt the motion, or it could trigger a House floor vote on whether McCarthy should remain Speaker.

Some House Democrats have signaled a willingness to help McCarthy remain Speaker if conservatives try to oust him, though they’ll likely want something in return.

If McCarthy refuses to support a bipartisan plan, some moderate House Republicans are considering joining with Democrats to force a vote on such a bill.

Either development would be extraordinary in modern politics and could send the House into even more turmoil.


Republished with permission of The Associated Press

Associated Press


  • Crap MAGAs

    September 29, 2023 at 7:45 am

    Once again the MAGA GOP wants to destroy America in their efforts to put Trump back in the White House . They could care less about how shutting down the government truly hurts Americans. They are all millionaires paid by the NRA

  • PeterH

    September 29, 2023 at 7:56 am

    Democrats should cooperate if they can accomplish two things with McCarthy:
    1. No stop gap spending bill for several weeks. Nothing will change in the GQP in a month’s time.
    2. If McCarthy is removed….. have enough Republicans support a Democrat speaker until Gaetz and his MAGA crowd can be thrown under the clown bus. Remove all committee assignments from the MAGA renegades.

  • Earl Pitts "Shut That _hit Down" American

    September 29, 2023 at 8:12 am

    Goot mornting America,
    To our over-spending elected officials:

    “Exorbatant spending is equlivant to being addicted to crack”.

    A continueing resulotion is like handing a crack addict more crack to help the addict “get off crack”.

    ****Important Instructions To The House Of Representatives From Earl****
    Shut That _hit Down.

    Thank you America,
    Earl Pitts American

  • Rick Whitaker

    September 29, 2023 at 8:16 am

    why is matt gaetz being allowed to screw up america so badly? why did floridians elect a punk like that to a national office? who are the big donors keeping him afloat? what can be done to expose him for what he is? these are all questions i wish i knew the answer to. the next election is too long to await his demise, but it’s got to be the end for him for the sake of our country and planet. gaetz is making florida look real bad.

    • Tropical

      September 29, 2023 at 8:38 am

      It probably doesn’t matter what gaetz does or as usual, does NOT do.
      Here in deep, deep red NW Florida they will continue to re-elect this clown.
      He always refuses to debate a challenger, because he’s just smart enough to know how to hold on.
      I still can’t name one thing of value that he’s done for my District.

      Hey, Earl Pitts -Stuffit.

      • Earl Pitts "Shut That _hit Down" American

        September 29, 2023 at 8:58 am

        Thank you for taking a knee to my, Earl Pitts Anerican’s, superior wisdom and joining my new Besty Lefty, Rick, and I. Earl Pitts American, on the conservative freedom train to American Exceptionlism, Tropical.
        You too may now relax your political sphincter but you need to prove your feility to me like Rick did prior to obtaining the coveted status of one of Earl’s Besty Lefties.
        Thanks and welcome aboard Earl’s Freedom Train.
        *queue anoyingly loud All American Patriotic music to further annoy all Dook 4 Brains Leftys*

        • WhatNow

          September 30, 2023 at 1:43 am

          – There you go again, “Earl the Arm Pits of America”, with your bizarre preoccupation with everyone’s sphincter muscles and now even the “_hit” that passes through them to go with it. And I hate to be the one to break it to you, but your statement of “…the conservative freedom train to American Exceptionlism” is what is known as an oxymoron.

    • Earl Pitts "Shut That _hit Down" American

      September 29, 2023 at 8:47 am

      Thank you for your feility and support Rick,
      I, Earl Pitts Ametican, knew you were always a “closet conservative” welcome aboard the conservative train my new “Besty Lefty”.
      Now you can finally “Relax your Political Sphincter” and begin to live a normal life based on solid “Grand-Pa Approved” conservative Judio-Christian values.
      Just imagine how proud your G.Mom and G.Pop in Heaven are now proudly watching rise from the horrors of Dook 4 Brains Leftism Rick …. Ya done good boy.

  • Michael K

    September 29, 2023 at 9:11 am

    Matt Gaetz is a petty little punk who is taking a personal feud with the Speaker to MAGA extremism with yet another performative stunt to grab a headline.

    Shutting down the government is stupid and reckless, and accomplishes nothing but economic pain across the nation and the world.

    We need legislators who understand that compromise is how government is supposed to function. What Gaetz is doing amounts to terrorism in the mistaken belief that this will somehow make him “qualified” to serve as Florida’s next governor. This is nothing more than raw political ambition by a spoiled little brat who is proving how unfit he is to serve.

    • Earl Pitts "Presudent of The Tater American

      September 29, 2023 at 9:34 am

      Great idea there Mike,
      I’m supprised that I, Earl Pitts American, did not think of it myself inside my own astute political genious brain. So supprised, in fact, that I am co-opting the idea and hence-forth it will be my briliant idea to install Matt as the next elected Florida Govornor.
      *News Break*
      “Earl Pitts endorses Matt Gaetz to be Florida’s next Elected Govornor”.

    • Earl Pitts "Presudent of The Tater American

      September 29, 2023 at 9:34 am

      Great idea there Mike,
      I’m supprised that I, Earl Pitts American, did not think of it myself inside my own astute political genious brain. So supprised, in fact, that I am co-opting the idea and hence-forth it will be my briliant idea to install Matt as the next elected Florida Govornor.
      *News Break*
      “Earl Pitts endorses Matt Gaetz to be Florida’s next Elected Govornor”.

        • Rick Whitaker

          September 29, 2023 at 9:44 pm

          he already probably hangs himself to achieve sexual gratification. have you noticed how he works a sexual comment into most of his comments. he’s so out of touch he still thinks potty humor is funny. they do it in grammar school often, but an 82 year old, now that’s strange. i got a buddy that lives near him. i’ll ask him if he’s heard anything like dick flashing in parking lots. that’s got to be his style. he mentions my name in his post, but i’m a straight man so he can back off. what a creepy guy.

        • WhatNow

          September 30, 2023 at 2:17 am

          – Trust me, he wouldn’t know how. Regardless, herein we should all strive to be respectful and civil, yes? “Respectful” of everyone’s White Christian God-Given Right – including Arm Pit And Sphincter Guy (as well as yours truly 😉 – to make a total fool of themself in public, and “civil” as in forgoing the crudity of suggesting that he hang himself when politely recommending that he honor his likely belief in eugenics by euthanizing himself with the finest pharmaceuticals available would certainly be far more genteel for use in our “polite” society here, yes?

          • Rick Whitaker

            September 30, 2023 at 7:04 am

            i’m very civil to my garbage bin. i gently place my trash inside and make sure the lid is closed. but flies do get in and maggot do build up. what now, i like your post. usually terse and witty, thanks

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704