A.G. Gancarski
Could the Republican presidential nominee repair issues with homeowners insurance in the Sunshine State?
Since the Republican Governor and supermajority GOP Legislature can’t do it, CFO Jimmy Patronis hopes that Donald Trump can.
Patronis, a potential candidate for Governor in 2026, says the “(Joe) Biden-(Kamala) Harris administration has been a complete disaster for the American people” when it comes to property coverage.
“According to the Wall Street Journal, homeowners’ insurance rates have increased nationally by over 37%, with first-quarter data showing a sustained increase into this year. And with rates exceeding 56% in Illinois, 48% in California and 54% in Texas,” Patronis asserted.
However, nowhere else has seen more acute insurance rate hikes than Florida, where the average policy costs homeowners roughly $1,000 a month, and where five cities in the Sunshine State lead the nation in shelling out to the insurance sector.
And though homeowners pay up, insurers often don’t pay out, failing to pay in nearly 45% of cases according to Weiss Ratings, which specializes in financial instruments including insurance and other products.
Despite these dismal numbers, the CFO blames Biden and Harris for Florida’s problem, and credits the Republicans running the state with “changed the laws in Florida to rein in frivolous litigation two years ago.”
Since then, “eight carriers have entered the state, 13 companies have filed for rate decreases, and there has been an 800% increase in take-out activity from Citizens Insurance, Florida’s carrier of last resort,” Patronis writes, before suggesting one potential solution being to compel European reinsurers to “abandon ESG mandates,” which he likens to the “Tower of Babel.”
Patronis also pings U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, who has pressed for details on Florida’s insurance market, including state-run insurer of last resort Citizens, which Gov. Ron DeSantis has said is “not solvent.”
The Rhode Island Democrat “has fired off letter-after-letter to Florida about climate change affecting the Florida insurance market, while failing to send such nasty-grams to California and Illinois where premium increases have been far worse,” Patronis notes, before offering “help” to Trump’s future “administration of patriots” in solving the issue.
Ironically, the biggest rate hike year over year in the DeSantis era was between 2019 and 2020, before Biden assumed office.
In an added irony, when DeSantis challenged Trump for the GOP presidential nomination in 2023, he took a remarkably detached view of the state’s insurance crisis. During a 2023 radio interview with a Boston host, he suggested homeowners should “knock on wood” and hope the state didn’t get hit by a storm.
It’s unclear if Trump believes this is a national issue, based on his excoriation of DeSantis’ “total sellout to the insurance companies” after last year’s reform legislation.
“DeSanctimonious is delivering the biggest insurance company bailout in global history. This is a gift to insurance companies and a disaster for the people of Florida,” Trump said. “He’s also crushed Florida homeowners whose houses were destroyed in the hurricane. They have been absolutely decimated. They’re getting pennies on the dollar.”
“The worst insurance scam in the entire country with the highest rates in the entire country. That’s Florida,” Trump added.
12 comments
Frankie M.
July 24, 2024 at 4:54 pm
Clean up our mess Donald…smh. I’d say these jokers are incompetent but that’s giving them too much credit.
MH/Duuuval
July 24, 2024 at 5:24 pm
The MAGAs know how to line their pockets. Take the current candidate dominating the airways with campaign ads, Tom Leek, who served in the House and now wants to be a Senator. He went from reporting assets of $800k to $16 million — in four years.
ScienceBLVR
July 24, 2024 at 5:06 pm
Despite these dismal numbers, the CFO blames Biden and Harris for Florida’s problem, and credits the Republicans running the state with “changed the laws in Florida to rein in frivolous litigation two years ago.
How long have we had the GOP leadership in FL doing nothing about property insurance. Song along with me, Jimmy,
Bush bones connected to the Crist(R) bone, Crist bone connected to the Scott bone, Scot bone connected to the well.. you get the idea, right Jimmy?
MH/Duuuval
July 24, 2024 at 5:20 pm
You have to give it to the MAGAS — they know how to reach the low-information voters with signs like “Stop the IRS Money Grab.”
tom palmer
July 24, 2024 at 5:57 pm
What gall. An administration that has been documented allowing the insurance industry to screw its policy holders suddenly shift the responsibility to someone else. Add to that the GOP’s decision to downplay climate change, which the insurance industry has long linked to their interest in whether to write policies at all in some parts of the world.
JustBabs
July 24, 2024 at 6:17 pm
That is hilarious. They really think he has the capability to solve an issue, any issue? Might as well look to his dog for answers. It would be the same. Take responsibility for your failures, Florida GOP, and ask for help from those who are actually successful at solving problems. Charlie Christ managed to get us above the last insurance crisis. Ask for advice.
PeterH
July 24, 2024 at 7:35 pm
“ … but it’s been worse in Florida than anywhere else for years.”
Of course insurance is more expensive in Florida. The real estate replacement cost is astronomical and most of the State is not more than 16’ above sea level. Actually….. Florida is very lucky to have ANY insurers willing to take the risk. Florida residents should expect MORE EXPENSIVE PREMIUMS. FLORIDA RESIDENTS SHOULD HAVE A PLAN TO RELOCATE AFTER A HUGE HURRICANE!
Phil Morton
July 25, 2024 at 6:02 am
Jimmy Patronis was unfit to be Florida’s CFO when he first ran and has done nothing to change that narrative since being elected.
Frankie M.
July 25, 2024 at 8:44 am
The worst insurance scam in the entire country with the highest rates in the entire country. That’s Florida,” Trump added.
I have to give him credit. If there’s one thing Trump knows about it’s scams. What would you say you do here Jimmy? I mean besides rail about culture war issues like DEI.
KathrynA
July 25, 2024 at 9:16 am
Wow, the state has done this to its residents and caused reputable companies to leave and brought in “fly by night”, unknown companies . They blame Biden and think Trump can fix this. He’s not president!! Do they even know this? This is Florida’s mess and exacerbated by climate change and strong hurricanes, but have left the residents in huge trouble. Only the very wealthy can afford to rebuild without insurance coverage after a catastrophe. Blame yourselves and start solving the problem and doing what is right for your citizens. Trump, the orange buffoon, can’t do it!! Get real, Jummy
retired state employee
July 25, 2024 at 12:21 pm
Jimmy, read the article – 45% of real claims are denied and you, who oversee the Dept of Insurance, have not gone after the bad actors even when it is proven. Campaign donations?
MAYBE DO YOUR JOB BEFORE YOU START LOOKING FOR THE NEXT ONE! Gov NOT
Jason M Crandall
July 26, 2024 at 12:55 am
Florida problems. Florida solutions. I thought DeSantis solved the homeowners insurance crisis?
Comments are closed.