Duval School Board member says district ‘gaming the system’ with test scores

Duval County School Board

Duval County School Board member Scott Shine has been so frustrated with the governing body that he decided not to run for re-election.

On his way off the board this year, Shine issued a stunning charge: namely, that the district is cooking the books when it comes to student test scores.

“A-F grades are designed to give parents clear, transparent measures of school performance,” said Shine. “If schools game the system, they are essentially lying to parents about the performance of their children’s schools.”

The gaming of the system, per Shine and the Florida Coalition of School Board Members, comes from alleged testing irregularities and grade inflation.

Per a media release from that coalition: “Duval County middle schools had a 66 percent civics pass-rate last year, which ranked 34 out of Florida’s 50 largest school districts. The district vaulted to no. 2 this year with an 84 percent passing rate. But while 8,649 students were tested in civics in 2017, only 5,739 were tested in 2018. That participation drop is likely the major source of the district’s gains. Similar patterns appear in Polk and Manatee Counties.”

The coalition focuses on gains at one particular perpetual D school — Matthew Gilbert Middle in the Durkeeville neighborhood, where all of the students are economically disadvantaged and 19 of 20 attendees are students of color.

The “pass rate increased 48 percentage points, to 95 percent. That passing rate is in the top 10 percent of schools in the state, and higher than any in St. Johns, Nassau and Clay Counties. But only 44 students took the test this year, compared to 144 the previous year.”

The bump in scores could, per the coalition, increase Matthew Gilbert to a C school, boosting funding and potential “political acclaim” for unnamed board members (perhaps including an intra-board foe of Shine’s, House District 14 candidate Paula Wright).

“We passed Schools of Hope to eliminate failure factories in the state of Florida and ensure every child in this state has access to a world-class education,” said Florida House Speaker Richard Corcoran. “We want to see schools make genuine improvements in teaching and learning. I am concerned some districts are inflating their results.”

Concern or not, this is at least for now a symbolic gesture, per a spox for the Department of Education.

“The Florida Department of Education takes very seriously the importance of valid measure and assessment of Florida schools. School grades will be released as soon as they are ready. There is an existing process for residents to raise concerns for the department’s review. At this time, we have no requests for an investigation from the Florida Coalition of School Board Members.”

Duval County Schools offered a lengthy defense of its methodology.

“The district is extremely excited about our student performance on the 2018 Civics End of Course Exam. The students’ incredible scores are a direct result of the tireless efforts of our teachers, students, and parents.  The 18-percentage point increase in performance on the Civics exam is consistent with increases students have demonstrated in other courses that end with a state end of course exam. In 2016, the district increased 12-percentage points in Biology. Last year, Algebra 1 and Geometry increased by 23 and 32 percentage points respectively.”

“Other districts have had major increases in scores as well. Hillsborough increased 14-percentage points in US History between 2013 and 2014, and Palm Beach increased 17-percentage points on the Civics exam from 2014 to 2015.”

“The number of students assessed in Civics in 2018 did decline. Each year, the district reviews the Student Progression Plan and Master Scheduling Guidelines. Through those reviews, multiple data points are reviewed and changes are made to better prepare students by adding prerequisites and course progression pathways. The Student Progression Plan and Master Scheduling Guidelines meet all requirements in state statute, state board rules, and Duval County Public School’s Board Policy Manual. Specifically for Civics, Law Studies was included as a recommended prerequisite for students based on their most recent FSA ELA score and Lexile Level.”

“This change is also consistent with Algebra I, Geometry, and Biology in the year of those major percentage point increases. Moving forward, there will be an increase in the number of students assessed each year. This is also consistent with Algebra 1, Geometry, and Biology. Each year, the district reviews the Student Progression Plan and Master Scheduling Guidelines.”

“The fact that any organization would call for an investigation into improprieties on assessments due to performance increases is an affront to all of the teachers and students who worked so diligently to prepare for the exam, and their families who supported them. We are very proud of their efforts, and our results on recent state and national assessments are a product of their continued pursuit of academic excellence.”

A.G. Gancarski

A.G. Gancarski has written for FloridaPolitics.com since 2014. He is based in Northeast Florida. He can be reached at [email protected] or on Twitter: @AGGancarski


  • Frankie M.

    June 27, 2018 at 1:21 am

    Sounds like Shine is pushing oppo from his charter school benefactor Gary Chartrand. How come he never talks about them gaming the system? I wish someone at the TU would follow the $$ like they did with the WWB story. I’d look to WJCT for help but they’re already muzzled by the Chartrand foundation. Some would see it as a conflict of interest but duval GOP members like Shine just see it as business as usual. As far as I can tell the only one gaming the system is Shine. He’s taking his ball and going home. Ever since his mancrush Vitti bailed on Duval for greener pastures Shine’s heart hasn’t been into his job of serving the students of dcps(not his bf former superintendent Vitti.) Or in the vernacular of the ol ball coach TC not Orr, “he’s been backing up to the pay window” the last year or so. P.S. How many school board members are currently in Chartrand’s pocket? How is he getting around campaign finance laws to stack the box?

  • Gregory Sampson

    June 27, 2018 at 11:29 am

    But when Vitti did it, by sending low-performing students from Geometry through “Advanced Topics” to avoid them bring down results on the state’s Algebra 2 test or by removing students from Algebra 1 into Algebra 1A based on low-performing December interim test results so they wouldn’t take the EOC and count in the results, Shine said nothing.;

  • Charlie K

    June 27, 2018 at 2:38 pm

    Your incoming Supt, Dr. Diana Greene had this to say on these allegations, “Don’t even try to act like we did something wrong..”

    The 8 members of FCSBM will soon be in the dust bin of FL education history either through quitting (Shine, Shawn Frost, Erika Donalds) or losing their re-election campaigns. Or in Richard Corcoran’s case, the man whose butt they kissed at every opp to gain favor and self-importance, getting laughed out of the Gov’s race after spending $5 million. You had your moment FCSBM, but now your benefactor is heading out to pasture, and parents/public are on to your corporate welfare give-away game. Don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn