Challengers lash absent Lenny Curry during televised debate

Early voting starts Monday.

Despite pressure to relent and just piggyback on a futuredebate involving all four candidates in the Jacksonville mayoral race, Action News Jax stood its ground.

And Friday night was the result: a showcase opportunity for the three challengers to incumbent Lenny Curry.

The conventional wisdom is that he’ll outright win the race in March. He skipped the pretape on this debate for an under-40 fundraiser that brought his campaign  another $50,000.

This, after a reported week of just $30,000 of fundraising, and another $250,000 sent to the Florida Republican Senatorial Campaign Committee for more ad buys.

In skipping the event, Curry let independent Omega Allen and non-machine Republicans Anna Brosche and Jimmy Hill stand together, attempting to distinguish themselves as singularly capable change agents.

Brosche and Hill have tangible beefs with Curry. Brosche and Curry split when she broke with administration edicts while President of the City Council. And Hill filed bankruptcy because his boat show went bust after the city went a different way on event scheduling.

Allen? Well, she ran in 2015. Disappeared. And is running again.

Curry likes his polling and talks as if the real election night surprise will be how close Brosche and Allen run to each other. He’s flooding the zone with television spots, and unlike Brosche, he has more than one positive commercial.

Brosche has been counterpunching since she filed. Her political committee’s current television ad is in third draft. And Curry hasn’t even played with the Sunshine Law schmozz yet.

There are plays in the playbook that may never get called once Brosche is defined. All that needs to happen, recall, is for Curry to win with 50.001 percent of the vote. One school of thought is that Brosche’s support will fall within a certain range,  north of twenty but south of thirty. If that’s the case, a runoff is unlikely, and Curry wins with roughly 57 percent.

He’s been polling in the fifties with a quarter undecided. His logic: Has anything upset the model?

With all that in mind, Curry had salient reasons for not debating. He’s running the four-minute offense, believing that his opponents choked and didn’t know the game before they jumped into the game.

And so it was that his opponents had a free kick on goal, the Friday night before the first day of Early Voting.  Turnout is anemic: 2.39 percent thus far.

Could the Friday night lights of the Action News Jax studios turn it around?

Some notes, below, in a debate that did not involve the candidates engaging each other once.

The production values were fine. But the atmosphere was antiseptic, devoid of the kind of territorial combat we saw at the end of the Mayor’s race four years ago.

In intro, Hill bemoaned not getting enough “face time” in the media. He is polling at three percent.

Allen went through her platform, earnest and non-combative.


“Most of you have only seen the lies Lenny Curry has spent four million dollars spreading about me, and I’m here,” Brosche said.

Brosche hammered the current state of affairs. Too much crime, not enough resources for the kids. Most of her talking points had been workshopped on the forum circuit.

When asked about a lack of public safety legislation, Brosche said she was “at the table” and pushed for more spending for children.

A former Council President and Finance Chair, she was in position to push for those priorities in budgets. However, her answers took a more holistic look at underfunding in general, saying that more children should be served through expanded programs.

“Teen diversion programs … Park managers … Parent education … Connecting kids to career opportunities … Bringing vocational education back into schools,” Brosche asserted as potential remedies.

Brosche went deep into parks, a concern she prioritized when she assumed the Council Presidency.

“Our parks need more love,” Brosche said.

Hill replied, “It’s not about parks, it’s about government.”

“Every part of our government is political right now … political deals with this administration,” Hill jabbed.

A recurrent Hill trope: to contend that Council districts that get jobbed in capital investment are only that way because their Council members have integrity.

At one point later on, Brosche and Hill had a remarkable exchange, one upping each other in daps about the correlation between integrity and economic disparity.

Hill then went on to discuss the Baptist and non-demoninational preachers who endorsed him because Curry didn’t veto the Human Rights Ordinance.

“There’s a failure. A systemic failure,” Hill bemoaned.

Brosche was asked about her Sunshine Law issues, an ultimately inconclusive investigation beyond Brosche and Councilman Garrett Dennis burning up the phone lines.

“There were no charges, indeed,” Brosche said, before stuttering on “Sunshine Laws” in a way that will be part of an ad soon a la “We’re all selling ourselves.”

Brosche also noted her lack of action on Confederate monuments, noting that it was not broadly supported by the public based on reaction. She proposed a Charleston-style “recontextualization.”

Allen went farther: proposing monuments be “removed, to a museum.”

Brosche soon enough slammed Curry for the proposed buyout deal on the Jacksonville Landing, calling the $15 million proposal a “political payout.”

Omega Allen was more direct, accusing developer Toney Sleiman of “mismanagement” and “gouging tenants.”

Soon enough, the debate devolved into spitballing of policy solutions, something that sounded like critiques of the weather from far outside the snow globe.

“We don’t know how many neighborhoods we have,” Brosche said, an allusion to an adversarial exchange with the “mayor’s staff.”

Omega Allen, asked about “social media,” said she wasn’t aware of “anything negative” about how any leaders used social media. Apparently she missed Curry’s “same s**t, different place” series.

“Same s% different place. Elected office is loaded w/ amateurs. Folks w/ no ability to implement ideas.Many are full of empty rhetoric & a false sense of self.They survive on the bottom w cheap talk.We will retire some in the fights that matter When it matters.”

Allen then took a jab at certain mayoral staffers, saying there was “no reason that someone should be making $200, $300,000.”

The salaries of both Chief Administrator Sam Mousa and Chief of Staff Brian Hughes are in that range.

When asked what the incumbent has done well, all three challengers dissed him.

“I don’t think he’s done anything well,” Allen said.

Brosche said that he’s done one thing well: “Breaking promises.”

From there, a litany of excoriations of the “vindictive” governing style of the Curry regime.

Early voting starts Monday.

A.G. Gancarski

A.G. Gancarski has written for since 2014. He is based in Northeast Florida. He can be reached at [email protected] or on Twitter: @AGGancarski


  • Karen

    March 1, 2019 at 8:27 pm

    Brosche did nothing as council President, is on an ego trip & has no platform beyond bashing Lenny. Hill had $$ problems, wrote the city a $12000 bad check, had no contract, is currently in bankruptcy and blames Lenny for his woes. Allen is a nice lady but too nice to survive in the dog eat dog political world. Lenny may not be perfect but who is!
    I’m with Lenny!!👍

    • Frankie M.

      March 1, 2019 at 10:38 pm

      After AG devoted half his column about the debate to someone who wasn’t even there the least the tv studio could have done is put out an empty podium for Lenny.

  • Amy Roberts

    March 1, 2019 at 9:05 pm

    After not attending an event where then President Obama was in Jacksonville, I was disheartened that the Mayor went “ fishing”. Talk about disrespect. Then the attempt and continued effort to sell JEA, gained my immediate attention and raised questions, the number one being, how is that going to benefit our City and his constituents. Moving on the acceptance of money from the UAE for assistance in what should have been funded in his budget, made me angry, WHY? Highly suspect of behind closed doors deals. Then working with former Governor Scott to stack the council, one that doesn’t actually live in the area he represents. I do hope the beautiful park that will be created when the Landing is torn down is utilized for many sponsored events for all, and not just a dock upgrade for Shahid Khan. I’m voting for Brosche.

  • Frankie M.

    March 1, 2019 at 10:32 pm

    I thought Hill came off well tonite. He has nothing to lose. Just a straight shooter with upper management written all over him. Brosche felt forced & scripted when staring at the camera giving canned responses. She was much better off the cuff in her rebuttals. More relaxed. She reminded me alot of Curry 4 years ago with his $3 smiles. Allen felt like the woman from the Simpsons who’s always screaming , “What about the children!”

  • Seber Newsome III

    March 2, 2019 at 6:49 am

    When asked about the Confederate Monuments, you could see the tension on Brosche’s face. So, now she wants to contextualize them, since she knows what a mistake she made in wanting them removed. Hopefully with Allen’s response to move them to a museum, which is impossible, maybe she will take some of those who would vote for Brosche. Why did they not ask Hill the same question?? Anyway, Princess Anna is on her way out.

    • Frankie M.

      March 2, 2019 at 10:08 am

      Seber I actually thought you would have liked her answer about bringing more monuments to Jax specifically the free one in Bama dedicated to the lynching victims? Isn’t that what you’ve been asking for? Black history right alongside southern pride baby!

      I admit the recontextualization reference sailed over my head unless she’s talking about a museum like Allen mentioned. Then again I didn’t really get the anti-LGBT support Hill was pushing. Especially for a guy who wants to be more inclusive than the incumbent.

  • jimmy

    March 4, 2019 at 2:30 pm

    its as if they almost warmed up to the idea that an outsider is about to shake this up in a way that disrupts the plan. I CAN’T WAIT TO READ WHAT IS WRITTEN ABOUT NEXT DEBATE.

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Renzo Downey, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Kelly Hayes, Joe Henderson, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Scott Powers, Gray Rohrer, Aimee Sachs, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Andrew Wilson, Wes Wolfe, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn