Aaron McKinney: Time for Florida Dems to embrace open primaries

"It’s time to stand up for independent voters and show them we value their involvement and participation."

Thirty-seven percent of Florida voters are registered Democrats. That’s a steep drop from 54 percent in 1990.

Republican voter registration has also plummeted, from 41 percent 20 years ago to 35 percent today.

Where are all these voters going?

They’re not going anywhere. They’ve been right in front of our eyes the whole time.

They’re registered, they’re ready to vote but they don’t want to join a party. We are witnessing a historic shift in voter affiliation in Florida and across the country.

The numbers of independent (NPA) voters are exploding and are growing faster than either major political party. 27 percent of registered voters-3.6 million Floridians — are now independents. And they are shut out of voting in Florida’s closed primary elections.

As an African American leader of the Florida Democratic Party, I believe we have two choices in how we relate to the growing ranks of independent voters, many of whom are people of color and young, like me.

We can cross our arms and say, “you must join our party if you want to vote,” or we can live up to our mission to be a party of inclusion, participation, diversity and progress, open the Democratic primaries, and build a new governing coalition for Florida.

I choose the latter. Open primaries.

If the Florida Democratic Party is going to continue its claim as the Party of inclusion, it’s time to stand up for independent voters and show them we value their involvement and participation. We have the legal authority to open our primary elections to independents.

The Supreme Court has ruled that political parties can supersede state election laws regarding who can and cannot participate in their nominating primaries. Unlike other election laws and statutes over which the parties have no control, the Florida Democratic Party could insist that unaffiliated independent voters be allowed to participate in our primary elections as early as 2020.

2020 will be a fiercely competitive primary election season with over 20 presidential contenders duking it out, but 3.6 million Floridians will be denied a say under the current rules.

The Florida Democratic Party has a golden opportunity to bring these voters into the conversation and into our vision for the future. It’s a once in a generation opportunity we cannot afford to squander.

Independents decide elections.

But since neither party reaches out to them until just before the general election, they swing back and forth between Democrat and Republican.

In 2008, Florida independents went for Barack Obama 52 to 45 percent. But in 2016, they preferred Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton by a margin of 47 to 42 percent. Two years later, they went for Andrew Gillum over Ron DeSantis 54 to 44 percent. And we should have done even better.

When Democrats lock millions of voters out of the primaries, it’s a tossup as to whether they will vote for us in November. Closed primaries are unfair, but they are also preventing Democrats from building a lasting majority.

Pew Research has found that a majority of independent voters consistently lean toward progressive values and issues. Even among conservative independents, Pew found them to actually be aligned with Democrats on many key policy issues, from immigration reform to same-sex marriage.

It’s not hard to understand why.

Younger Americans, including young voters of color, have the highest rates of political independence. 50 percent of millennial voters now identify as independents. Their turnout has nearly doubled since 2014, and for the first time, they cast more votes than baby boomers in the 2018 midterm elections.

These are natural Democratic Party allies, and they want to vote.

We risk losing an entire generation of open-minded voters if we don’t embrace and respect their desire to identify and register as independents. They will vote for our candidates.

But not if they feel disrespected.

The media sometimes projects that independents are all “angry white men.” That’s not true.

Independents are as diverse as our state, and their numbers are growing in communities of color.

Too often, our party has gone to communities of color with a backward-looking message: “We have to defeat the Republicans, or you will lose what little you have.”

It’s an out-of-touch approach, indicative of flawed or antiquated tactics. African American and Latino voters young and old are growing tired of this approach, and rightfully so.

Witness the 1.6 million African American voters who stayed home during the 2016 election, the first decline in turnout in over 20 years, and a Latino voter turnout that held steady from the previous election despite a significant voter registration effort.

Our party should be sending a clear message to all Floridians that the Democratic Party has a vision of progress, democracy and participation. And we don’t just talk the talk, but we walk it like we talk it — shoutout to Gillum.

Bringing independent voters into the Democratic Party’s nominating process brings us more in line with our own values and gives us a distinct advantage that will pay dividends in general elections for years to come.

The Miami-Dade Democratic Party just passed a resolution urging the Florida Democratic Party to open its primaries in 2020 and every election after.

Several other county parties have passed similar resolutions or are actively considering them. These resolutions will have a full hearing at our party’s convention in October.

I hope every Florida Democrat will stand with me, support a move to open primaries, and build a new progressive future for Florida.


Aaron McKinney is a former State Senate political staffer and State Committeeman for the Miami-Dade Democratic Executive Committee.

Guest Author


  • Mary Pezzi

    June 6, 2019 at 3:25 pm

    Imagine if an automated system sent a Voter Card to everyone on their 18th birthday, which was valid for life (period, no exceptions.) Imagine if people were able to vote for the best candidate for president, based on ISSUES and not party-affiliation. That would bring us a lot closer to being a true democracy. And it only makes sense. Everyone should be encourage to vote by removing as many road blocks as possible. Anything less is voter suppression — and of course both major political parties accuse the other of voter suppression, and both major parties accuse all third-party voters of being “spoilers.” Especially in Florida there’s a lot of voter suppression. People are REQUIRED to register as a Democrat or a Republican if they want any say in the primary elections. All registered voters, who are not affiliated with any party aka Independent Voters should be able to vote for one candidate running in the primary elections. Sure, fewer people would join a party, UNLESS they really felt that party represented their core values. Maybe that’s what Democrats are afraid of because currently, the corporate-wing of the Democratic Party has been able to control the party via big-money donors, superdelegates (that represent corporate-interests and big donors) and the DNC /DCCC establishment (that chases the Republicans further and further to the right.) Without RULES that require party-affiliation to vote in the primaries, and rules that require voters to register a party-affiliation changes at least 59 days before a primary… well, probably more young voters would participate and of course, they are more progressive.

  • Jim Donelon

    June 6, 2019 at 8:59 pm

    I must take exception to Mr. McKinney claim. Instead of allowing voters who want to CLAIM to be independent to invade the primary system, how about making the Democratic Party more inviting to the general population so more folks would be inclined to register as Democrats. With that in mind, I assume Mr. Mc Kinney will be voting this weekend in Orlando to do away with the weighted voting system that counties -like Miami- use within the Democratic Party to maintain the tight control they have had for decades. Now that would be a beginning to make the party more open. I’ll be watching to see if Mr. McKinney walks the walkj and not just talks the talk.

    Jim Donelon, President – St. Petersburg Democratic Club

  • Taylor McG

    June 7, 2019 at 6:12 pm

    I would much prefer an open primary, I’d rather vote for the person and their platform rather than A PARTY I don’t support. And entering and changing party affiliation in order to vote for a person
    -and frankly I’m tired of this two party system that doesn’t represent my beliefs.

  • gary

    June 8, 2019 at 12:20 am

    As always no deeply seeded long term concerns for the people of Florida. Simply go after groups, races and genders. Typical Democrat laziness! Trump 2020 is a walk over! Thanks dems

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Drew Dixon, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Cole Pepper, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Drew Wilson, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn