A sometimes angry, defiant and determined Puerto Rico Gov. Ricardo Rosselló accused Washington D.C. Friday of “turning its back on” Americans on the island since Hurricane Maria
Rosselló called on Puerto Ricans in Florida and others to respond in elections.
Speaking to a packed room of about 500 people at the Kissimmee Civic Center, Rosselló unleashed a torrent of frustration over a nation that made promises to help the island (and its residents) and has failed to do so since.
The Puerto Rican Governor was in Florida for the first time since Hurricane Maria devastated the island on Sept. 20-21, and since hundreds of thousands of his constituents fled to Florida because so much of the island remains without power, potable water, and much of a functioning economy.
Rosselló was joined at the podium by Florida Gov. Rick Scott, Florida’s Democratic U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson, U.S. Rep. Darren Soto, and Kissimmee Mayor Jose Alvarez, who all also spoke to a crowd that was so much larger than expected that the room had to be expanded twice before the program started.
The gathering also included more than a dozen other elected officials and candidates, including Orange County Mayor Teresa Jacobs, state Sen. Victor Torres, and Democratic gubernatorial candidate Gwen Graham.
While Rosselló’s New Progressive Party is generally aligned with the stateside Republican Party of Scott, Jacobs, and President Donald Trump, and while in the early weeks after the storm he and Trump appeared to be united, he struck a strongly different tone Friday.
Rosselló said the island government and Congress and Washington struck a deal through the PROMESA act passed in 2016 to address Puerto Rico’s economy and debt, and that the island government lived up to its end with massive cuts and changes in labor laws. But after Hurricane Maria, many of those in Washington who had made promises “turned their back on Puerto Rico, and not only forgot about us, but made things increasingly worse.”
“This is where we have to draw the line in the sand,” he said. “This is where we need to be outraged, outraged, by the inadequate response for U.S. citizens who live in Puerto Rico.”
“A storm that, as evaluated by third parties, was a thousand-year storm … Maria is the most devastating natural event in the modern history of the United States of America, make no mistake about it. This is why there are challenges of unprecedented nature, and this is why we needed a response of unprecedented nature,” Rossello said.
He spoke of Puerto Ricans’ love for American citizenship, but said Puerto Ricans have been treated as second-class citizens for a century, and he accused Congress and leadership in Washington of breaking promises just in the past few months.
“We fight the same wars, we have the same citizenship and we deserve that equal and fair treatment. After the storm, when the world was watching Puerto Rico, people started to say, ‘Hey? How come the response is so fast in some places in the United States yet so slow and so filled with obstacles in Puerto Rico?'”
Rosselló drew a standing ovation when he finished the 26-minute speech.
In his speech, Scott pointed out all of the things Florida has done to help both the island and the evacuees, from sending utilities experts and crews to the island to widespread waivers of state rules so that Puerto Ricans could more easily settle in to live in Florida. Rosselló also announced $1 million is being added to CareerSource to help Puerto Rico evacuees find work in Florida.
Rosselló thanked him for that and acknowledged that all the work he and his staff have done for the island, and said the channels of communication with the island’s government, “means a lot to us and the people of Puerto Rico.”
But he heaped more praise on Nelson, who likely will face Scott for the 2018 U.S. Senate race in Florida, declaring, “It’s hard to find a better friend than Sen. Nelson has been for the people of Puerto Rico.”
Rosselló then said similar things about Soto and Alvarez, and called on Puerto Ricans in Florida and across the country to remember who has been their friend, and who has not, and to send a message by registering to vote, and then voting.
He called on the six million Puerto Ricans in the United States, including more than a million in Florida, to exercise their power to “make things right, not only on the island, but to make things right for yourself as well. We have this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity right now.”
Rosselló said America has “no moral standing” to preach democracy for Cuba, Venezuela, Iraq and Afghanistan until it addresses full citizenship for Puerto Ricans.
“How do we make this happen? We make this happen not just by talking, but by acting. And I am committing myself here to coming to Florida and to other states as well to organize our communities, so that we can make them know what the issues are, and make the distinctions between those have been friends to Puerto Rico, and those that have turned their back, and we can be influential in the up and coming midterm elections.”
Alvarez, Soto and Nelson all set the tone in criticism of the federal government and Congress in its Puerto Rico response.
The Democrats decried everything from slow recovery efforts — 40 percent of islanders are still without power more than 100 days after the storm — to the passage last month of a tax reform package that penalizes Puerto Rico with a new excise tax.
With immediacy, Soto said FEMA is telling evacuees in Florida that their housing vouchers are being canceled Saturday because the agency determined their homes back on the island are habitable, even though some still have no electricity, and some do not even have water.
Recent Florida citrus estimates are steady for the first time since Hurricane Irma struck Florida.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s January estimates reflect no change from December’s, marking the first stable citrus forecast since the storm.
The USDA in October forecasted 54 million boxes of oranges for 2017-2018 production. In November, that forecast dropped to 50 million followed by another decrease in December to 46 million – an estimate that remained for January’s forecast.
And yet, while seemingly stable, the forecasts are dismal.
Florida Department of Citrus Executive Director Shannon Shepp said the state’s citrus industry still faces its lowest forecast in more than 75 years.
The monthly forecasts are best guesses; the real numbers come after the growing season ends. It’s those figures that tell the story of citrus in Florida.
Along with Irma, the state’s citrus industry has been hit by the citrus greening epidemic. The so-far incurable disease attacks the fruit, causing it to turn green and bitter, and eventually killing the tree.
“While the temporary comfort of a stable forecast gives us a moment to breathe it doesn’t hide the fact that this industry remains in crisis due to the impact of Hurricane Irma,” Shepp said.
In the 2016-2017 season, Florida produced close to 69 million boxes of oranges. Florida growers are looking to the state and federal government for remedy.
“Florida’s iconic citrus industry and its growers continue to struggle with the unprecedented damage caused by Hurricane Irma,” Agriculture Commissioner AdamPutnam said in a separate statement.
“This damage, combined with the cumulative impacts of citrus greening, leaves Florida’s growers in desperate need of support,” he added. “I will continue to work with Gov. (Rick) Scott and leaders in Washington to get Florida’s growers the relief they need to rebuild and replant.”
The U.S. House of Representatives passed an $81 billion disaster spending bill. A $2.6 billion agricultural assistance package for Florida growers was included in that bill.
State estimates reported an estimated $2.5 billion crop loss to Florida growers following Irma. The state’s recurring message is that the storm “could not have been more lethal” to Florida citrus.
Scott’s proposed “Securing Florida’s Future” budget recommends $22 million for the Sunshine State’s citrus industry. Lawmakers are sure to address the situation when crafting their own budget this Legislative Session.
By joining FirstNet, Florida will now become just a little safer in times of emergency.
Last month, the state of Florida (quickly followed by California) became the final entry in the nationwide public-safety broadband network, part of a public-private partnership between FirstNet and telecommunications giant AT&T. The announcement by Gov. Rick Scott came just hours ahead of the Dec. 28 opt-in deadline.
This under-the-wire decision now means that all 50 states — as well as three U.S. territories — are part of this ambitious public-safety program.
Inclusion in FirstNet gives Florida agencies currently running on Motorola Solutions Project 25 (P25) radio networks an immediate benefit by their addition to this new national, high-speed broadband system.
Established by Congress in 2012, FirstNet allows AT&T to set up an LTE radio access network within each state’s borders — at no cost to the state.
Offering greater ease of communication, FirstNet represents a quantum leap for public safety, a critical advantage in emergencies such as severe weather. When Florida communities face disaster, as in the case of September’s Hurricane Irma, seconds matter. Milliseconds can be the difference between life and death.
In those situations, first responders and law enforcement just can’t afford to lose radio communications.
Before FirstNet, Florida first responders, consumers and businesses have been sharing a common commercial communication network. During heavily attended events or significant emergency situations, these shared resources can quickly become problematic — and potentially deadly. Systems become congested, and calls lost, creating a nightmare for first responders, as well as a potential public-safety crisis.
A major hurricane, or an upcoming Super Bowl, can have thousands of users all accessing phones simultaneously. At the same time, first responders using the same network are also trying to share critical issues.
As anyone frustrated by a dropped cellphone call knows, not being able to communicate in an emergency is devastating.
Nationwide, first responders use more than 10,000 voice networks, many of which do not work well together, with often tragic results (notably during the 9/11 terror attacks in 2001).
One answer came when the federal government set a national P25 standard for public safety voice communications, solving the problem for voice calls. With a universal standard across the country, FirstNet will do the same for data applications.
FirstNet, in conjunction with P25 land mobile radio (LMR) networks, will be America’s first dedicated, interconnected public safety network exclusively designed for first responders. The result will be a platform for communication and collaboration that reaches across local, state and national agencies.
Motorola Solutions, a leader in P25 communications worldwide, is collaborating with AT&T in Florida to deliver this innovative network for first responders in the state and beyond.
This partnership will also expand coverage throughout the state — particularly in underserved rural areas that lack reliable, secure public-safety communications in times of natural disaster or emergencies.
As part of FirstNet, Motorola customers in Florida can bridge their standards-based P25 systems to the new nationwide data network.
In Florida, 28 counties work under the P25 System. Motorola Solutions serves 25 of those counties as a vendor of choice for public safety radio communications, including Broward, Pinellas, Palm Beach, Orange, Leon and Columbia.
Under FirstNet, they will all have access to the new generation of productivity, with enhanced public safety specific applications and devices. Motorola public safety customers will also receive the highest priority in accessing the FirstNet system.
For example, Motorola Solutions’ premier LEX F10, a rugged public-safety LTE handheld device specifically designed for first responders, is certified by AT&T as “FirstNet ready.” That means the device can at once be used to enhance existing equipment — offering seamless communications when it is needed most.
Also, FirstNet’s communications network will also support Motorola’s other land mobile radio networks.
Motorola Solutions is no stranger to partnering with AT&T, past collaborations have resulted in developing cutting-edge mobile apps, software, and other services; FirstNet is just the latest role for Motorola in its goal of supplying both high-quality broadband devices and solutions for Florida’s public safety needs.
Cape Coral Republican Rep. Dane Eagle detailed a pair of bills he’s sponsoring Tuesday, one of which would provide property tax relief for Floridians whose homes were damaged by Hurricane Irma.
“Many Floridians have been unable to live in their primary residences due to the destruction caused by Mother Nature through Hurricane Irma, and adding insult to injury, they have received a property tax bill from the government for their damaged property,” Eagle said. “The Hurricane Irma Tax Relief Act will allow these homeowners to apply for a tax abatement for the days their home was uninhabitable and will allow them to retain more of their much-needed, hard-earned money.”
The bill, HB 1375, would require homeowners to apply for the tax break before March 1, 2019, and those applications must be reviewed and approved by county property appraisers by May 1, 2019.
The amount of the abatement would be based on the percentage difference in a home’s value post storm compared to its assessed value on Jan. 1, 2017, as well as the number of months the home was uninhabitable. Under the bill, if a home was unlivable for 16 days out of a month then whole month would be counted toward the abatement.
If the tax abatement comes out higher than a homeowner’s total property tax bill for 2019, the money would carry forward and apply to their 2020 tax bill.
Eagle also detailed another bill he’s sponsoring, filed in October, that would allow people who have received “not guilty” verdicts for criminal charges to have their records expunged.
HB 1075 would not apply in the case of certain serious crimes, such as sex offenses, kidnapping or fraud, though current law does not allow for expunction for any cases that make it to trial regardless of the verdict.
“Current law allows for an individual to expunge certain arrests once over a lifetime if the charges were dismissed or if adjudication of guilt was withheld. Expanding this opportunity to those who exercised their constitutional right to a fair trial for certain crimes and were found not guilty is simply the right thing to do and can better help these individuals find gainful employment and become productive members of society,” Eagle said.
HB 1075 has been referred to the Criminal Justice Subcommittee, Judiciary Committee and Justice Appropriations Subcommittee. HB 1375 was filed Monday and has not yet received committee assignments.
“It’s disappointing that there are financial hurdles for the information that the people of Florida deserve to have,” Graham said.
Graham, a Democrat hoping to replace Republican Gov. Rick Scott in November, was billed the amount after she accused his administration of hiding the documents she requested. But Scott’s administration said the amount charged was a result of staffers working 100 hours to review and redact her the information at a $12 per hour rate.
McKinley Lewis, a spokesman for the governor’s office, said Graham’s request was “unique” and while other media outlets have made similar requests for information, Graham got the bill because she asked for the information first, which launched the “extensive work.”
Now that the governor’s office has received the check,Graham’s requestis being finalized and will be made available online “very soon,” Lewis said.
Graham’s campaign spokesperson, Matt Harringer, said she plans to make the information available to the public as soon as she gets it.
Her request revolves around the call logs, text messages and voicemails that went to the governor’s private phone before the hurricane hit the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills and knocked the facility’s power out. His phone line was made available to nursing homes and assisted-living facilities for emergency purposes.
Graham wants to know what role the governor played in these deaths and why some voicemails were deleted, which she deems to be a violation of state public records laws.
“What I want are the voicemails,” she said, “that’s what I want and I hope the voicemails will be included in the request.”
If they are not included, she said she will “take the appropriate legal action.”
Following the evacuation of the Hollywood nursing home, fourteen elderly residents died. Twelve of those deaths have been ruled homicides and legal fights have ensued.
Florida lawmakers will start the 2018 Legislative Session Tuesday, with Gov. RickScott giving his annual State of the State address.
During the subsequent two months, the House and Senate will negotiate a state budget and consider hundreds of bills. Here are 10 big issues to watch as the Session moves forward:
Scott has proposed an $87.4 billion spending plan for the fiscal year that starts July 1. The proposal includes politically popular ideas such as boosting education funding and providing tax cuts. But the proposal is only a starting point for lawmakers, who are expected to face a tight budget. A September analysis estimated a slim $52 million surplus for the coming year — and that did not account for the state’s costs from Hurricane Irma.
Eyeing money from a 2014 constitutional amendment about land and water conservation, lawmakers will consider a series of proposals that could shield property from development and restore waterways. For example, Senate budget chief RobBradley, a Fleming Island Republican, has proposed spending$100 million a year on the Florida Forever program and wants to set aside $50 million a year for the restoration of the St. Johns River, its tributaries and the Keystone Heights lake region in North Florida.
House Republican leaders likely will renew a push to ease health-care regulations, an effort they say would help increase access to care and lower costs. Examples include eliminating the “certificate of need” approval process for hospital building projects and ending a restriction on patients staying overnight at ambulatory surgical centers. Such proposals, however, have died in recent years in the Senate amid opposition from parts of the hospital industry.
Senate President Joe Negron, a Stuart Republican, has made a top priority of revamping the higher-education system and will continue seeking changes during his final term. Senators are expected to quickly approve a bill that would make permanent an expansion of Bright Futures scholarships and take steps to further bolster need-based aid. Negron also wants changes such as holding universities to a four-year graduation standard in performance funding.
When Hurricane Irma smashed into Florida on Sept. 10, it reset priorities for the 2018 Legislative Session. Lawmakers are considering dozens of ideas for responding to Irma and preparing for future storms. For instance, they are looking at possibly providing financial help to the agriculture industry, which took at least a $2.5 billion hit in Irma. They also will grapple with Scott’s push to require long-term care facilities to have generators and fuel to keep buildings cool when electricity goes out.
Insurance lobbyists will try to persuade lawmakers to revamp laws dealing with a controversial practice known as “assignment of benefits,” which the industry blames for increased property-insurance costs. The practice involves policyholders signing over benefits to contractors, who then pursue payment from insurers — often leading to disputes and lawsuits. Lawmakers also will consider renewed proposals to eliminate the state’s no-fault auto insurance system.
House Speaker Richard Corcoran, a Land O’ Lakes Republican, has made clear he wants to continue expanding school-choice programs, which draw opposition from Democrats and many public-school officials. The House has started moving forward with a bill that would offer voucher-like scholarships to students who are bullied in public schools. Meanwhile, the House and Senate face a key budget disagreement on the use of increased property-tax revenues in funding public schools.
With overdoses skyrocketing and families being torn apart, lawmakers will look for ways to address the state’s opioid epidemic. Scott wants to spend $53 million to address the issue, with much of the money going to substance-abuse treatment. Scott and lawmakers also could place limits on initial opioid prescriptions that doctors write for patients. The idea is to prevent patients from getting hooked on prescription painkillers and then moving onto potentially deadly street drugs.
Since taking office in 2011, Scott has made cutting taxes a hallmark of his administration. As he enters his final Legislative Session, Scott has proposed $180 million in tax and fee cuts. The proposal, however, does not include major changes in the tax system. Instead, it includes a 10-day sales tax “holiday” for back-to-school shoppers and reductions in motorist-related fees, including fees for obtaining and renewing driver’s licenses.
Texting While Driving
Lawmakers in recent years have repeatedly rejected efforts to toughen the state’s ban on texting while driving. But the issue has a better chance of passing during the 2018 Session after Corcoran announced that he supports making texting while driving a “primary” offense. Currently, it is a “secondary” offense, meaning motorists can only be cited if they are pulled over for other reasons. But if it is a primary offense, police would be able to stop motorists for texting behind the wheel.
Sen. Jose Javier Rodriguez wants to know if the state will take any independent action against drug companies for their role in the state’s opioid epidemic.
“As we all know, this is now, and has been for some time, a full-blown public health crisis, and there is no time to waste,” Rodriguez wrote to Attorney General Pam Bondi Friday.
Last year, Bondi announced a multistate investigation to look into potentially unlawful practices in the distribution, marketing, and sale of opioids, but no update has been given to the public yet.
Bondi’s office said it has “publicly announced that our investigation includes: written requests for documents and information, known as civil investigative demands or subpoenas.”
But Rodriguez, a Miami-Dade Democrat, wants to know if the office has received responses from drug companies.
“More specifically,” he said, “I would like to know whether your office has taken any steps outside of the multistate investigation to determine if whether these drug companies should be held liable for their role in the opioid crisis.”
The latest numbers show that in 2016 there was a 35 percent jump in opioid-related deaths from the previous year.
Legislators are considering options this Session to stop the spread of drug addiction and patients’ dependence on prescription medicines that could lead to the use of deadly drugs like heroin and fentanyl.
Coming up, the usual assortment of tidbits, leftovers and not-ready-for-prime-time moments by Ana Ceballos, Jim Rosica, Danny McAuliffe, Andrew Wilson and Peter Schorsch.
But first, the “Takeaway 5” — the Top 5 stories from the week that was:
Trump, Scott on drilling — Republican Gov. Rick Scott and Democratic U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson both opposed President Donald Trump’s Interior Department plan to potentially open up Florida to offshore oil drilling. Scott, a close ally to Trump, is widely expected to run against Nelson, a Democrat, to take away his Senate seat in 2018. After Trump unveiled his plan to allow oil and gas drilling in federal waters, including Florida, Scott said his “top priority is to ensure that Florida’s natural resources are protected.” White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said the Trump administration’s goal wasn’t to cross Gov. Scott, and in essence, that they should agree to disagree.
DeSantis is officially in — Republican Rep. Ron DeSantis has entered the crowded Florida Governor’s race, and he comes in with the endorsement of President Donald Trump and millions of dollars in his pocket. He announced the decision Friday and said he wants to “drain the swamp in Tallahassee. While the move was not unexpected, his rivals in the governor’s race were quick to attack him. Adam Putnam called him a “typical Washington politician who is focused on nothing more than his next promotion.” Democrats clenched to his close ties to Trump with Andrew Gillum saying he is now “even more determined to spend 2018 fighting against the Trump agenda & standing up for Florida’s working families.”
Jeb! endorses Jimmy — Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis, who is running for a second term, picked up the endorsement of former Florida governor and presidential candidate Jeb Bush. The former Republican House member was appointed by Gov. Scott as CFO in June, and as he readies for another term, he is likely to face Sen. Tom Lee in the Republican primary. While Lee has said he will run for CFO, he has not yet filed the paperwork. It is not the first time Lee has had similar aspirations. If we take a look back at the archives, Lee ran a failed campaign in 2006 to be CFO, when Bush was governor. Back then, Lee reeled in the endorsement of Bush.
Hammer’s request of Latvala — It’s been a couple of weeks since Sen. Jack Latvala resigned amid sexual harassment and quid quo pro allegations. And now, a prominent National Rifle Association lobbyist has asked him to give at least $1 million in his leftover campaign funds to children with disabilities. Marion Hammer wrote a lengthy open letter to Latvala asking him to make a “profound difference” and donate some of the money he raised in his bid for governor to the Dyslexia Research Institution, for which she volunteers. POLITICO Florida’s Matt Dixonreported that there is a growing fear among Florida politicos that Latvala could “use millions of dollars in remaining campaign funds to attack political foes that he believed orchestrated his ouster.” When Latvala resigned, he blamed unnamed “political adversaries” for booting him out of office.
Strapped for cash — The Florida Democratic Party has been scrambling to raise money, after two fresh-off expensive wins. But entering into a busy election year with several high-profile, contentious races on the horizon, including the governor’s race and a few statehouse races, the party has approximately $414,000 in the bank. To raise more money, newly-elected Chair Terrie Rizzo has asked county-level leaders to contribute cash for eight regional positions and her financial team has also requested Democrats across the state to pitch in. In a 21-day fundraising effort, Rizzo’s team pulled in $253,000 before the year’s end — more than half the cash it has on hand.
Gov. Scott continues effort to aid Puerto Ricans
Gov. Scott gave an update this week on how the state is helping the thousands of hurricane-displaced Puerto Ricans.
Since the island was walloped three months ago, the governor’s office estimated about 297,000 people have traveled to Florida from Puerto Rico. While it is unclear how many of those have stayed in the state, school districts give an indication.
Florida schools have seen a spike in enrollment since the hurricane season. Scott’s office reports that more than 11,200 students from Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Island have enrolled since Oct. 3, 2017.
The governor’s office also reported that about 500 law-enforcement officers have been deployed on security missions to the island and that the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicle relief center at the Orlando International Airport has assisted more than 10,700 people seeking driver’s licenses, ID card, and other vehicle-related services.
Scott, DOH announce $5 million in grants for Alzheimer’s research
Gov. Scott and the Florida Department of Health announced this week a list of Alzheimer’s disease research projects that will receive a combined $5 million in grants through the Ed and Ethel Moore Alzheimer’s Disease Research Program.
“These grants support research programs across the state that are looking to find new treatments and preventions that give hope to finding a cure for this heartbreaking disease,” Scott said. “We are proud to build on our commitment to the many individuals and families who have been affected by Alzheimer’s and look forward to seeing the continued success of Florida’s world-class research community.”
Secretary of Health Celeste Philip thanked Scott and the Legislature for their part in keeping state money flowing to the grant program, and commended the board that oversaw the selection process for picking “high-impact projects that represent our state’s agenda of prevention, recognition, treatment and family support.”
The grant money will primarily fund research studies at Florida universities, though the Mayo Clinic and the Mount Sinai Medical Center will also receive funds. The projects were selected through a competitive process open to all researchers in the state.
The University of Miami will pull down the most significant chunk, about $1.18 million, to fund a half dozen projects. UF will receive about $940,000, followed by USF at $821,000 and UCF at just under $500,000. Other schools across the Sunshine State are set to get smaller grant awards.
Peace River Camp, a camp solely for disabled veterans, celebrated its grand opening this week with Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam on hand for the ribbon-cutting ceremony.
The new camp, which includes on-site sleeping facilities, a screened-in kitchen, fire pit, dining area and restrooms, is located within the Peace River State Forest in DeSoto County. It joins Camp Prairie, near Lake Wales, as the state’s second camp solely for wounded veterans.
Both facilities are part of the “Operation Outdoor Freedom” initiative championed by Putnam and helped along by private donations.
In addition to the camps, the program provides wounded veterans with opportunities to enjoy outdoor activities ranging from guided alligator hunts to kayaking at no cost. Such events are held on state forests, private lands and along the coasts.
In order to use the Operation Outdoor Freedom camps or go along on the excursions, veterans must be honorably discharged with either a service-connected disability rating of at least 30 percent, or be the recipient of a Purple Heart.
This week in appointments
Gov. Scott this week announced the following appointments and reappointments:
— Kelvin Lawson and Dr. Matthew Carter to the Florida A&M University board of trustees
Lawson, 54, of Jacksonville, is a vice president at Acosta Sales and Marketing. He previously served as the director of national accounts for Johnson and Johnson. He is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending Jan. 6, 2021.
Carter, 65, of Tallahassee, is an attorney and business consultant on energy, economic development, and education with Carter and Associates. He is an Army veteran and previously served as a member of the Board of Governors of the State University System. Carter is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 6 and ending Jan. 6, 2023.
These are subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
— BlakeGable to the Florida Gulf Coast University board of trustees
Gable, 46, of Naples, is chief executive officer of Barron Collier Companies. He has served as a board member of the Immokalee Foundation and as a trustee of the Greater Naples YMCA. Gable is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 6 and ending Jan. 6, 2023. This appointment is subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
— Dr. Athena Randolph and Kathryn McInnis to the Florida Gateway College District board of trustees
Randolph, 60, of Lake City, is co-owner of Randolph Medical Practices. Randolph is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2019.
McInnis, 71, of Old Town, is a retired occupational specialist for the Dixie County School Board. She is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2021.
These appointments are subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
— KevinMadok to the Florida Keys Community College District board of trustees
Madok, 55, of Big Pine Key, is clerk of courts for Monroe County. Madok is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2020. This appointment is subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
— Four to the Lake-Sumter State College District board of trustees
Bryn Blaise, 29, of the Villages, is the construction manager for the Villages Commercial Property Management. Blaise is appointed to fill a vacant seat for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2019.
Bret Jones, 38, of Clermont, is the principal attorney and owner of the Law Offices of Bret Jones, P.A. He is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2021.
MarciaButler, 73, of the Villages, previously taught in the Pinellas County school system. Butler is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2021.
TimMorris, 59, of Leesburg, is the vice president of Ernie Morris Enterprises, Inc. Morris is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending May 31, 2021.
These appointments are subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
— Dr. DanielCalvo to the Board of Occupational Therapy
Calvo, 40, of Lakeland, is the regional consultant of clinical services for Accelerated Care Plus. He is reappointed for a term beginning Jan. 5 and ending Oct. 31, 2021. This appointment is subject to confirmation by the Florida Senate.
FDACS recovered $148K for consumers last month
The Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services said it recovered more than $148,444 last month for consumers scammed out of their money by Grinchy businesses.
The department received about 2,500 complaints in December, which led to 150 new investigations and 19 arrests. The agency also tacked on another 11,744 telephone numbers to Florida’s Do Not Call List.
Businesses on the naughty list last month included moving companies, vehicle repair shops, pawnshops, health studios, telemarketers, travel sellers and others.
Consumers who believe a business has bilked them out of their money or have suspicions that fraud has taken place can contact the department’s hotline at 1-800-HELP-FLA, or 1-800-FL-AYUDA for Spanish speakers.
Florida Health announces radon-themed contest winners
In celebration of National Radon Action Month, Florida Department of Health is announcing the winners of the 2018 Florida Radon Poster and Video Contest.
The contest was launched as an opportunity for students to educate communities about the dangers of radon, the top cause of lung cancer among nonsmokers and the second-leading cause of all lung cancer.
“I want to congratulate the contest winners and thank all of the students who entered this year to help raise awareness of radon,” said State Surgeon General and Secretary of Health Philip.
The Florida Department of Health announced this week that it would work alongside the USDA to expand a program that reimburses child care providers that provide nutritious meals.
“Building lifelong healthy habits starts in childhood,” said Secretary of Health Philip. “The Child Care Food Program promotes healthy habits by exposing young children to nutritious foods to help them make healthy food choices. We encourage parents seeking child care in Florida to enroll their children in facilities that participate in this program.”
The Child Care Food Program is offered at child care centers, family day care homes, after-school programs, homeless shelters and some emergency shelters. DOH keeps an up-to-date list of participating facilities on its website.
Kids in Head Start and children from households receiving Food Assistance Program or Temporary Assistance to Needy Families benefits are automatically eligible to receive free meals benefits at participating facilities.
Tom Lee files ‘fiscal transparency’ bill
Sen. Tom Lee, a Brandon Republican, introduced a bill this week that would expand the scope of the Legislative Auditing Committee review to include compliance with transparency requirements.
Under the bill, the reporting requirements for specific local government economic development incentives would be revised. It would also require local government to post certain property tax information and history on their websites.
A similar bill in the House championed by state Rep. Colleen Burton has been prioritized in the chamber and is set for a vote on week one of Session.
Burton’s bill requires local government to post certain voting record information on websites and property
Currently, local governments are required to have a CPA conduct an annual financial audit if the Auditor General has not already scheduled a review.
Robert Asencio bill aims to keep jobs in Florida
A proposal filed by Miami Democrat Asencio would cut state-backed benefits for Florida businesses that shift focus from the Sunshine State.
Under HB 1171, any company that plans to move 30 percent or more of their business out of Florida would have to give a six-month notice to the Department of Business and Professional Regulation and would become ineligible to receive grants, state-guaranteed loans, or tax benefits for five years.
“We have a duty to do everything we can to help Florida’s working families. So, it makes no sense that these companies, who up and leave Florida, damaging our families, communities and our economy as a whole, would be eligible for grants, loans, or tax benefits backed by the state,” Asencio said. “It’s time we invest in the local businesses who intend to stay in our state and ensure that no companies who are here for the short term take advantage of Florida’s resources.”
The bill would put companies eyeing an out-of-state move on a public list, and businesses that try and skirt the law by not reporting their intentions to DBPR would face fines of up to $10,000 a day unless they have a good excuse for skipping town.
Bills filed to help seniors ‘age in place’
A bipartisan effort seeks to “exempt the sales tax on home improvements that help seniors age in place,” according to a news release.
Rep. LoriBerman, a Lantana Democrat, and Sen. KathleenPassidomo, a Naples Republican, filed the legislation (HB 1123, SB 1448).
“The tax-exempt items would include bed transfer handles, handrails, bed rails and grab bars, stair lifts, shower seats and furniture recliners, all of which make homes safer for seniors and allow elderly adults to retain more independence,” the release says.
Passidomo said her district “is home to many seniors who are fiercely independent and want to remain in their homes as long as possible. These exemptions will help them to do just that.”
Berman added: “By helping the elderly to afford equipment that allows them to remain in their homes, we’re helping them maintain dignity, self-sufficiency and their overall well-being.”
The Florida Association of Area Agencies on Aging and the Florida Alliance for Retired Americans both have endorsed the bill.
ACLU: Stop ‘cruel anti-immigrant’ measure
Saying that the ‘sanctuary city’ bill prioritized by the Florida House is about “codifying racial profiling into law,” ACLU officials are asking supports to tell their representatives to oppose the bill.
“We have to keep the pressure on if we’re going to beat this terrible bill,” the ACLU’s email blast read. “Tell your representatives to protect Florida communities.”
Proponents of HB 9, which will head to the floor for a vote on week one of the 2018 Session, say the bill is about following the rule of law and about public safety.
The ACLU says it is about “putting a target on the back of people of color across Florida.”
This bill will drive victims and witnesses into the shadows, corrode community trust in law enforcement, drain valuable law enforcement resources, and make Florida less safe, according to the ACLU.
FFRW announced 2018 legislative priorities
The Florida Federation of Republican Women advocacy group has released its picks for the 2018 Session and are asking women to help promote their agenda.
Among their stances this year are opposing the “sanctuary city” ban bill — one that is prioritized by the House — supporting bills that help prevent human trafficking and educate students about the signs of such crimes as well as giving more aid to homeless veterans.
The group is also supporting two measures that ban a person from lobbying a community redevelopment agency until he or she has registered as a lobbyist with the agency, and making texting while driving a primary offense under state law.
The organization consists of thousands of women who have supported and worked for candidates they believe “will represent the interests of women through responsible governmental policies.”
Solar groups back bill to put up panels in the Keys
The Solar Energy Industries Association and Vote Solar came out in support of a bill filed this week that would fund a pilot program to showcase how a combo of solar power and energy storage can keep critical facilities online during natural disasters.
HB 1133, sponsored by Monroe County Republican Rep. Holly Raschein,would deck out critical facilities in the Florida Keys with on-site solar generation and storage so they can make it through major grid outages without a lengthy downtime.
“As we’ve recently experienced firsthand with Hurricane Irma, there’s nothing more crucial in the wake of a disaster than power. On-site solar energy storage systems are a forward-thinking solution to improving the security of energy supply at critical local facilities,” Raschein said. “Given that Florida is the Sunshine State, it only makes sense to tap into this resource when planning for stronger communities that are more resilient in recovering from a disaster.”
Solar groups agree, with SEIA CEO Abigail Hopper calling the bill “a crucial step in preparing Florida for future emergencies.”
“Making sure our first responders and critical facilities have the power they need to deliver lifesaving services during emergencies should be a top priority for any state, and solar plus storage is the easiest and most effective solution,” she said. “This pilot program will demonstrate the effectiveness of solar and storage in maintaining grid resilience and help lawmakers implement this strategy on a larger scale.”
PIFF releases its 2018 legislative priorities
The Personal Insurance Federation of Florida has released its annual list of legislative priorities and this year some of those include addressing the costs of any repeal of the motor-vehicle no-fault law, a bill that Uber is supporting.
PIFF says that repealing the no-fault law would have to include reasonable reforms to the state’s third-party “bad faith” law. It also wants to see legislators preserve a “proven, transparent and performance-based premium tax credit.”
The organization is in support legislation that eliminates the Assignment of Benefits, which PIFF says is the cause for homeowners’ premium increases in the state.
“In 2018, we believe the key priority should be to meaningfully address assignment of benefits (AOB) reform in a way that reduces fraud and abuse, and thereby reduces costs,” said Michael Carlson, the president of PIFF.
Senator praises undefeated UCF Knights
After an undefeated season and a Peach Bowl championship title, Sen. Linda Stewart congratulated the student-athletes that make up the University of Central Florida Knights.
“UCF has demonstrated to the entire nation that our undefeated hometown team is No. 1 with a 13-0 perfect season,” Stewart said. “I am proud of the incredible performance by our true national champions, the undefeated UCF Knights. Charge on!”
Gas prices highest in three years
Motorists in the state saw the highest prices in the last three years, averaging 3 cents more per gallon than the year before.
The highest average price for gasoline in the state last year was $2.73, 6 cents more than the national average. Prices were at their peak early in September and at their lowest in July.
“Gas prices normally decline during January and February, as gasoline demand hits the lowest levels of the year,” said Mark Jenkins, a spokesman for AAA.
Florida gas prices are some of the most expensive in the Southeastern part of the country. Within the state, the cost for fuel spikes in West Palm Beach-Boca Raton, Miami and Fort Lauderdale. Gas is least expensive in Jacksonville, The Villages and Orlando.
Oil analysts believe the market is somewhat inflated due to geopolitical tensions and supply concerns, Jenkins said.
FSU Sport Management program ranked No. 1 in nation
The Florida State University has the top sports management program in the nation, according to the independent online publication College Choice.
The master’s degree program in Sport Management at the university was graded on five key data points to receive the honor. That includes quality, reputation, affordability, value and student satisfaction.
“We are incredibly proud of the recognition our program has received,” said Jeffrey James, professor and chair of the Department of Sport Management. “This achievement is a reflection of our outstanding faculty, staff and students, and we aim to keep this momentum going.”
The program, housed in FSU’s College of Education, gives students a lesson plan that includes courses on sports marketing, sports and the media, legal issues in sports as well as a service-learning program.
Florida State continues rise in Kiplinger’s ‘Best College Values’
There’s more bang for your buck at Florida State University, according to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance, a money-focused publication that annually ranks colleges by best values.
The rankings reflect an educational return on investment. The investment is the cost of attendance.
Kiplinger ranks schools in different categories. One of the most noticeable rankings for FSU is its No. 4 status among public colleges in best value for out-of-state students.
For in-state tuition at public institutions, FSU climbed to the No. 14 spot. It landed at No. 63 across both public and private colleges. The University of Florida grabbed the No. 32 spot overall. Both institutions are well ahead of the next Florida university on the list: The University of South Florida at No. 115.
“Florida State University’s commitment to academic excellence and student success is the driving force behind our continuing rise in Kiplinger’s rankings,” said Sally McRorie, who is provost and vice president for academic affairs at FSU. “Our laser focus on high achievement serves our students well during their studies and after graduation.”
Kiplinger’s system has caught the eye of the Florida Board of Governors, too. The BOG considers the rankings when determining pre-eminence for universities.
Out with the old, in with the new
What better way to bring in the New Year than to get rid of outdated electronics and hazardous household waste?
The Leon County Solid Waste Management Division will hold the next Household Hazardous Waste & Electronics Collection Saturday, Jan. 6, from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m., at the Public Works Operations Center, 2280 Miccosukee Road.
Citizens can bring up to 50 pounds of hazardous waste, in addition to their electronics, with some provisos:
— Only one large-screen television per vehicle will be accepted.
— Propane tanks must weigh less than 40 pounds.
— There is a limit of one tire per participant.
— There is also a limit of 25 fluorescent tubes per vehicle at the collection event.
— Medical sharps, medicines and radioactive waste cannot be accepted.
— Bulky wastes such as appliances (refrigerators, stoves/ovens, washing machines, dryers, etc.), and furniture, yard waste, construction and demolition debris, household garbage and Styrofoam cannot be accepted.
The event is free for residents, but businesses and other agencies still must call (850) 606-1816 to make an appointment, Monday through Friday, to drop off their items at the Leon County Hazardous Waste Center, 7550 Apalachee Parkway. Some fees will apply.
And residents can always visit the Leon County Hazardous Waste Center during normal business hours, Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. For more information, call (850) 606-1803 or go toLeonCountyFL.gov/HHW/collection for the complete collection schedule and safe packing guide.
Leon County opens Northeast Trail
The county will host a ‘grand opening’ of a multiuse-use trail Monday, Jan. 8, at 2:30 p.m.
Located at the intersection of Thomasville Road (U.S. 319) and Proctor Road, the two-mile trail will be open to hikers, bikers and runners. It’s the newest addition to Leon County’s trail system.
At the grand opening, County representatives will be joined by Tallahassee Mountain Bike Association, Gulf Winds Track Club and Chiles High School Cross Country Team. To find other Leon County recreation facilities, visit LeonCountyFL.gov/Parks.
City of Tallahassee OKs settlement in public record suit
A landmark settlement agreement with the Tallahassee Democrat was approved this week in a lawsuit alleging public records law violations when the paper requested text messages.
The paperreportedthat the City Commission unanimously approved the settlement after it admitted it violated the Florida Public Records Act when it failed to produce text messages of former City Manager Rick Fernandez.
Fernandez “got four tickets worth $2,000 for a lobbyist’s box office seats to a Florida State University football game that he previously denied receiving,” the paper has reported. Text messages eventually surfaced showing an exchange about the tickets between Fernandez and the lobbyist.
The suit promoted a series of new city policies and procedures related to the retention and production of text messages. It also revised its use cellphones for city business following the case.
City Commissioner Gil Ziffer thanked the Democrat for bringing the issue to the public’s attention, adding that the city needs “to set an example.” Ziffer, who is running to be Tallahassee’s next mayor, said the city needs to be more diligent about preserving text messages and that he plans to make it a priority this year.
Tallahassee family receives free car from Recycled Rides Program
Universal Collision Center in Tallahassee recently partnered with MetLife Insurance, Brehon Family Services, and the National Auto Body Council to present a local family with a much-needed lift. Kelsey and Dante Boyer received the keys to a fully-restored 2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee. The Boyers were identified by Brehon through their participation in the Healthy Families program.
“Many of us take transportation for granted but would be unable to live our daily lives without it. It’s been a tremendous honor to support a deserving local family by helping them obtain a safe, reliable vehicle. We hope this is just the first of many families we can put on the road,” said Universal Collision Center’s Sheryl Driggers.
Recycled Rides is a community action initiative where members of the National Auto Body Council, insurance companies and collision repairers partner with local non–profit organizations to provide deserving individuals and families with the gift of a fully-restored vehicle. Since the program’s inception in 2007, the National Auto Body Council donated more than 1,000 vehicles.
Universal Collision Center brought the Recycled Rides program to Tallahassee, joining with the Brehon Family Services organization to select a family in need. Universal Collision obtained the vehicle from MetLife Insurance Company. As part of the Recycled Rides effort, Universal Collision technicians voluntarily repaired the vehicle involved in the event.
“This incredible gift is life-changing,” said Jackie Malone, executive director of Brehon Family Services. “It’s so exciting when businesses find creative ways to support families in our community. The Boyer family now has easier access to work, education, child care, health care and other daily necessities. We are so grateful to Universal Collision Center, MetLife Insurance and the National Auto Body Council for their generosity.”
The Boyers participate in Healthy Families Gadsden/Leon, a voluntary family support and coaching program that helps parents provide the safe and stable environments children need for healthy growth and development.
Now for this week’s edition of Capitol Directions:
Gov. Rick Scott‘s office wants $1,200 from Gwen Graham before it will deliver anything to respond to her public records request, contending that’s how much staff time cost to research her inquiry into whether he spoke with nursing home administrators during the September 2017 tragedy at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills.
The governor’s office sent an invoice for $1,200 to Graham after her campaign issued a press release Thursday alleging that Scott and his office had not responded to her September open records request. In that press release, Graham, a leading Democratic candidate aiming to succeed Scott as governor, demanded, “What is Rick Scott trying to hide?”
In September Graham had followed up on media reports that had suggested Scott may have had telephone contact with nursing home officials during the slow-motion tragedy that unfolded at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills.
During the several days of power outage following Hurricane Irma, 14 residents died from heat exposure. Several investigations of the tragedy have been launched, including a criminal investigation.
Graham filed a records request under Florida’s public records laws for communications between Scott and his staff and nursing home administrators, particularly focusing on cell phone activity, but also seeking records from state agencies involved.
Thursday morning, more than 90 days later, Graham and her campaign charged that Scott had not responded to her records request, and appeared to be stonewalling.
The response came hours later, in a letter dated Thursday contending that the executive office of the governor had spent about 100 staff hours researching what records might apply to Graham’s request, and for that she must pay $1,200 to reimburse taxpayers before anything might be delivered.
“Ms. Graham,” the Office of Open Government wrote, “Upon review of your records request for the item “Copies of phone records (not limited to, but including call logs, text messages, and voicemails) from the phone account Governor Rick Scott gave out to healthcare executives for hurricane emergency related issues,” it has been determined that a cost estimate of taxpayer dollars spent is required, pursuant to Chapter 119.07(4)(d). To produce Governor Rick Scott’s September and October 2017 personal phone logs, approximately 100 hours of staff resources have been expended. This has been due to the strenuous time and resources that were dedicated to determining the identification of each individual number on the phone logs, as well as then identifying each call as state related business. The hourly rate indicated on the cost estimate is that of the lowest hourly rate of an individual who assisted with this assignment. This cost estimate has been provided in order to recover the taxpayer dollars spent processing this request.
“Please find the cost estimate attached to this email. As always, please feel free to reach out with any questions,” the office advises her.
Graham, a former congresswoman from Tallahassee, is pushing open records and government transparency in her campaign seeking to succeed Scott as governor. Her campaign’s press release Thursday alleged that “Scott and the all-Republican Cabinet have paid more than $1 million to settle lawsuits stemming from public record violations. And, last month, Scott pulled the plug on Project Sunburst, an online database of the governor’s emails.”
She faces fellow Democrats Chris King of Winter Park, Tallahassee Mayor Andrew Gillum, and former Miami Beach Mayor Philip Levine, and Republican Agriculture Commissioner Adam Putnam.
“Governor Rick Scott does not care about transparency. Throughout his administration he has shown a complete disrespect for the spirit and letter of the Sunshine Laws,” Graham stated in the news release. “Florida used to be proud of our transparency laws. Scott has made a mockery of them.”
Duke Energy and Tampa Electric Company asked the Public Service Commission this week to approve plans that would allow them to pass to ratepayers more than $600 million in costs related to Hurricane Irma and other storms.
Duke Energy’s proposal would see the company collect $513 million from customers, who would see their average bill jump by $5.20 a month. The proposal would increase bills in March and would run for three years.
“This past hurricane season impacted Florida significantly, from damaging homes and infrastructure to affecting agriculture and tourism. Duke Energy Florida understands the impact this filing has on both our residential and business customers,” Harry Sideris, Duke Energy Florida state president, said in a prepared statement Thursday. “We will continue making smart investments to significantly enhance service reliability throughout the year, including during storm season.”
Duke’s commercial and industrial customers would see spikes between 2.5 percent and 6.6 percent if the plan is approved by the PSC.
TEC is seeking $87.4 million to help it recover from this year’s storms, with $77.7 million of that sum due to Irma. That proposal would also start in March and last for three years. The rest of the money would pay for costs related to hurricanes Matthew and Hermine in 2016.
Under TEC’s plan, residential customers who use 1,000 kilowatt-hours of power a month would see their bill jump by about $4 for the duration.
In both plans, the bulk of the money will be used to replenish reserves depleted by Irma as well as pay for additional costs brought by the storm.
Nearly three-quarters of Florida voters say they could not vote for a candidate who has been accused of sexual misconduct, according to a new statewide public opinion poll conducted by Gravis Marketingof Winter Springs.
Gravis found almost widespread agreement on that position. Voters in nearly all age groups, genders, religious affiliations, races, and education backgrounds overwhelmingly agreed with that position. Overall, 72 percent of registered voters polled said they could not vote for someone accused of sexual misconduct, while 28 percent said they could, and almost all demographic breakouts showed at least 65 percent also saying they could not vote for someone accused of sexual misconduct.
Among Republicans, 46 percent said, yes, they could vote for a candidate accused of sexual misconduct. Those who called themselves “conservative” or “very conservative” weighed in at 46 and 47 percent yes, respectively.
Among Democrats, 87 percent said they could not vote for a candidate accused of sexual misconduct, and among independents, 74 percent said they could not.
The findings were among several public opinion issues Gravis polled last week in matters also including gay marriage, needle sharing, greyhound dog racing, the federal tax reform law approved by Congress and signed by President Donald Trump last week, gambling, gay conversion therapy, and the performances of Gov. Rick Scott and Trump to prepare for and respond to Hurricane Irma back in September.
Gravis reported it conducted a random survey of 5,778 registered voters from Dec. 19-24, citing a margin of error of 1.3 percent.
Many of the queried issues did not inspire absolute majorities on positions, but a few did, including an overwhelming [70 percent] approval of Scott’s overall job performance dealing with Hurricane Irma. Support for gay marriage and needle sharing programs, and opposition to gay conversion therapy also drew majorities, albeit tighter.
Scott and Trump also got pluralities approving of their performances managing nursing homes and other medical facilities during Hurricane Irma, but uncertain votes left both of them without absolute majorities on those questions. Forty-four percent approved of Scott’s performance relating to nursing homes and medical facilities during Irma, and 30 percent disapproved, perhaps tied to the shock and concerns raised by the tragedy in Hollywood Hills. Trump drew 46 percent approval and 45 percent disapproval on the same question.
Fifty-nine percent of voters told Gravis they support the legalization of gay marriage, while 30 percent opposed.
Forty-six percent of voters said transgender individuals should not be banned from using the bathroom of the gender with which they identify, while 36 percent said they should be banned from doing so, with the rest of voters uncertain. When locker rooms replaced bathrooms in the question, the spread was 43-38 saying they should not be banned.
Forty-eight percent of voters said they supported legalizing poker and other forms of gambling in Florida, while 30 percent opposed.
Fifty-seven percent said they supported needle exchange programs, while 19 percent opposed.
Forty-six percent said greyhound dog racing should be made illegal in Florida, while 32 percent said it should remain legal.
Forty-six percent also opposed the federal tax bill approved last week, while 37 percent supported it.
Sixty-nine percent believe “gay conversion therapy” should be illegal in Florida, while 11 percent think it should be legal.
Many of the issues, particularly those involving gay and transgender questions, saw strong partisan splits, with Democrats and Republicans overwhelmingly lining up on opposite sides, and strong pluralities or majorities of independent voters preferring the Democrat’s primary positions. The same was true of the tax reform bill, which got 73 percent support among Republicans; 27 percent support among independents; and 8 percent support amend Democrats.
The gambling and greyhound opinions were much more uniform across party affiliations. Pluralities of Republicans and independents opposed dog racing and supported gambling, while slight majorities of Democrats opposed dog racing and supported gambling.