Winner and Loser of the Week in Florida politics — Week of 9.25.22

After the catastrophe of Hurricane Ian, leaders came together for the common good.

Often when calamity strikes, we look for someone to blame. This time it’s different though. After Hurricane Ian, everyone just wants to help.

That starts with the détente between President Joe Biden and Gov. Ron DeSantis, and it was so good to see these men put people ahead of politics. There’s no need to repeat all the insults DeSantis hurled at the President because what was past doesn’t have to remain the prologue for what Florida needs now.

The Governor is a staunch opponent of top-down federal mandates like we saw during the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, Florida can’t handle something like this by itself. Only the federal government can muster the resources to help on the scale Florida needs, and Biden promised DeSantis that help will keep coming.

“My view on all this is like, you’ve got people’s lives at stake, you’ve got their property at stake and we don’t have time for pettiness,” DeSantis said on Fox News. “We’ve got to work together to make sure we’re doing the best job for them, so my phone line is open.”

Well said, sir. Please keep saying that.

We might call Florida a state that’s increasingly red, but this isn’t about that. It’s about grandma and grandpa’s retirement home crushed by wind and flood waters. Businesses were obliterated within a matter of hours. Roads and bridges were wiped out, adding to the complication of getting aid to those who need it most.

It’s a sense of helplessness about those family members and friends still missing. And yes, it also is about realizing that it will be years before the parts of Southwest Florida that took direct hits will recapture any sense of normalcy.

The political stuff will work itself out. DeSantis took a few jabs about his vote against Superstorm Sandy while he served in Congress, but none of that matters now. Maybe leaders on both sides of the aisle can look at the shattered faces of Fort Myers and Naples and realize you don’t play the “red state-blue state” game in times like this.

It’s about people, not politics.

Now, it’s on to our weekly game of winners and losers.


Honorable mention: Rick Scott. When he served as Florida’s Governor, you knew things were about to get really bad when he showed up wearing a Navy ball cap. That meant a hurricane was coming and it was time to stock up on canned goods.

Still, it was oddly reassuring to see Scott at those times because you knew he was in charge. He rose to the occasion when Florida was threatened by monstrous storms.

Scott was at it again as Ian approached. He was proactive in the days leading up to the storm.

I’ve reached out. I’ve been talking to Sheriffs. I’ve reached out to the Governor, but I’ve been talking to Sheriffs, police departments, state workers. I’ve talked a couple times to the CFO, Jimmy Patronis,” Scott told Jim Cantore of The Weather Channel.

He added, “So I told them, I told all of them: I spent eight years as Governor. I’m going to do everything I can to make sure every federal resource is there. If you need any help, tell me. I’ll tell you what I can do, whatever I can to be helpful.”

As best we can tell, DeSantis didn’t return Scott’s call. That probably had something to do with Scott’s pointed comments about the state’s property insurance crisis. But, that’s their problem.

The point is, Scott knows a thing or three about crisis management during a major hurricane. And like we said before, everyone just wants to help.

Almost (but not quite) biggest winner: Patronis. He was a key player in the days before Ian struck and as CFO he will have an outsized role in helping Floridians recover. For now, though, let’s concentrate on what he did as Ian approached the Southwest coast.

He sounded the warning for Floridians to prepare while Ian was well off our shores.

In a public service announcement, he stressed an important step in pre-storm preparations.

“Tropical Storm Ian, in the next few days, will more than likely become a hurricane. What I want you to do is take your smartphone, go walk outside your house, and shoot a video of what it looks like today. Then, go back inside your house and shoot that same video inside,” he said.

“If you are affected by this storm, this will give you a cut-and-dry example of what your house looks like before and after the storm if you had damage. You’ll have that to take to your insurance company in order to have a cut-and-dry claims process. God bless, stay safe and visit for your own hurricane plan.”

Good advice.

The biggest winner: Kevin Guthrie. In his biggest test since taking over last year as Director of the Florida Division of Emergency Management, Guthrie has been a steady hand on the wheel.

A key move was to ask people who planned to shelter in place during Ian to register with the state so workers could check on them after the storm passed. About 20,000 people did so, and by Thursday an estimated 10,000 had been contacted and confirmed safe.

That’s a great tool for rescue workers, especially in a devastating storm like this one.

One of the grim tasks in a situation like this is confirming the number of fatalities. That total is likely to increase in the days ahead.

“Let me paint the picture for you. The water was up over the rooftop and we had a Coast Guard rescue swimmer swim down into it and he could identify what appeared to be human remains,” Guthrie said at a news conference. “We want to be transparent, but we just don’t know that number.”

Managing an emergency like this one takes a methodical, compassionate and organized approach. Guthrie, who had a tough act to follow in former Director Jared Moskowitz, was all those things.


Dishonorable mention: Political ads during a catastrophe. Look, we know the election is a little more than a month away, but have some basic decency, huh? No one wants to see self-serving political TV ads during a disaster.

But they saw some anyway.

TV spots for DeSantis, Val Demings and Marco Rubio competed for attention, and that was just unseemly. In fairness, Demings did pull spots from the Fort Myers and Tampa Bay markets in advance of the storm.

Charlie Crist, who hopes to defeat DeSantis, announced earlier he wouldn’t advertise in Fort Myers and in the Tampa Bay market when it looked like it could get a direct hit.

That prompted this anonymous quote from a Democratic consultant to POLITICO.

“This is not the time to go off the air,” the person said. “Somebody needs to tell Charlie Crist it’s not 1992. It’s 2022 and the rules of the game have changed.”

In the same piece, former Gov. Jeb Bush said, “I think campaigns should shift to helping what will be hundreds of thousands of Floridians that will need a lot of assistance.”

Almost (but not quite) biggest loser: Rubio. There was an interesting story on about the buddy-buddy relationship between Rubio and financial adviser Bernie Navarro. 

Last year, Navarro — who runs a private equity mortgage company — extended Rubio a perfectly legal $850,000 bridge loan. There’s nothing unusual about that. Such loans are often used in real estate purchases to allow a person to buy another home while waiting to sell the one they have.

OK, so what’s the big deal?

Three months after getting the loan,  Rubio appointed Navarro, his longtime friend, to an advisory committee that helped select potential nominees for federal judgeships. Navarro has no law degree or legal experience.

Rubio got the loan in January 2021, but didn’t disclose it until his financial form on Aug. 30 of this year.

As Salon noted, the Southern District Judicial Advisory Commission, where Navarro was appointed, picks finalists for several important federal appointments in south Florida, including U.S. district judges, U.S. marshals and the U.S. attorney.

Adam Bozzi, vice president for End Citizens United, told Salon he saw a clear “threat of conflict of interest” in Rubio’s relationship with Navarro.

“It becomes worse when you actually are in debt to the person and you put them on a board that gives them special access (to give) advice to you,” he added, “and it becomes even worse when you don’t disclose it.”

The biggest loser: Francis Suarez. The Miami Mayor should have been pretty busy last week. For a time it looked like his city could feel damaging effects from Hurricane Ian.

And as the New York Post reported, he was busy — busy attending two political fundraisers in New York City while, back home, residents were under tornado and flood watches.

Those same residents didn’t know the Mayor was, as the Post reported, at the exclusive Casa Cipriani private club and Le Bilboquet, described as a “posh Upper East Side French restaurant.”

He was engaged enough to tweet that residents should “stay informed & stay safe.”

Except, well, those same residents might have wanted to be “informed” of the whereabouts of their Mayor.

Joe Henderson

I have a 45-year career in newspapers, including nearly 42 years at The Tampa Tribune. Florida is wacky, wonderful, unpredictable and a national force. It's a treat to have a front-row seat for it all.


  • Toni Pollock

    October 2, 2022 at 8:25 am

    Let’s put Scott and Rubio in the place they belong. The recent federal budget extension which contained funds for FEMA to help with the recovery from Ian came up for a vote. Rubio didn’t bother to show up…as usual, and Scott voted no.

  • Tom

    October 2, 2022 at 8:57 am

    You say you want to be Governor.

    Nothing prepares you for the task and job, you confront the hand that is dwelt.

    Natural disasters:
    Hurricane, 145 mile winds, category 4/5.
    Devastation. Loss of life, people’s lives up ended.
    500 yr floods, property destroyed. Everything lost.
    100 year pandemic, lives and basic society at risk.
    Surfside collapse, natural disaster. Lives lost, horrendous.

    Challenges make the person. This Gov gets an A plus! God Bless the people’s Gov.


    1. The survivors and people’s hit by the storm!

    2. First Lady Casey DeSantis, her raising of money for disaster aid relief, outstanding! A bright light for Florida, and America one day soon.

    2. Emergency Relief workers and law enforcement. These dedicated servants at local level especially, with state and federal help, are invaluable. Bless them all.

    3. Governor Ron, making the difference with his staff, like Kevin Guthrie and others. The people’s Gov. at work. Getting relief and services going to help all. The waffle house stop by, invaluable. The right touch.

    Losers: POTUS Biden, asking if dead Congresswoman, Jackie Walorski is in audience. Sad. Worse, VPOTUS Harris referring to North Korea, standing in the DMZ, as an ally. Just horrendous. You can’t make this clown show up. So sad. Destroying America’s economy, and foreign policy. Brutal.

  • Hope

    October 2, 2022 at 9:25 am

    No one can trump the biggest losers of the week, Brandon and VP Kamala.

    These two should be awarded The Biggest Loser award every week they are in office. Their failures so many to mention knows no bounds whether it is national security, the economy, inflation, border crisis, or crime… it’s time for impeachments. In a little over a month that will finally begin.

  • Ocean Joe

    October 2, 2022 at 11:48 am

    Biggest losers: Folks who think big government is the enemy. Only big government, federal assistance can fix this.

    Second Biggest losers: Climate deniers and the politicians who pander for their votes and are in the pocket of big oil. If this is a 500 year event, as the governor states, we just had Dorian and Irma. A 500-year event annually is unsustainable. The cost of taking major steps to deal with change is far lower than ignoring it.
    Kicking the can down the road is the GOP’s specialty. Ignore, distract, blame, but do nothing.

    Third biggest loser: the author for cheering on Rick Scott, a publicity hound trying to worm his way into this disaster while always voting against federal aid for others, not to mention his scurrilous past. He has no business holding public office, and hopefully Francis Suarez, Miami mayor dissed here, will primary and beat him when he is next up. Desantis has done a good job.

    We have another month of hurricane season to go.

  • Tom

    October 2, 2022 at 12:40 pm

    Ocean you liberal tard, lmao with your climate cry. Go cry with Sen. klobachur.

    Let’s not dump on Joe H. Ex Gov Scott was almost comical in getting people to leave on t v. He did a good job as gov on hurricanes.

    I always find it ironic that federal tax payers pay taxes, meaning they earn income, work and we’re told we have to be thankful for our govt to assist? Really? We, I pay for it!

    5 million illegals entered in 20 months? My money, our money is going to illegals.

    How bout the billions to Ukraine? Really?

    You are wrong ocean.

    As FP legend I’m honored you jumped in based upon my regular Sunday outline. I’d think you would have praised one or two. Be sure to waive to Brandon, ask him if dead Cong. Jackie is here. Pathetic.

Comments are closed.


Florida Politics is a statewide, new media platform covering campaigns, elections, government, policy, and lobbying in Florida. This platform and all of its content are owned by Extensive Enterprises Media.

Publisher: Peter Schorsch @PeterSchorschFL

Contributors & reporters: Phil Ammann, Renzo Downey, Roseanne Dunkelberger, A.G. Gancarski, Anne Geggis, Kelly Hayes, Ryan Nicol, Jacob Ogles, Gray Rohrer, Jesse Scheckner, Christine Sexton, Andrew Wilson, Wes Wolfe, and Mike Wright.

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @PeterSchorschFL
Phone: (727) 642-3162
Address: 204 37th Avenue North #182
St. Petersburg, Florida 33704

Sign up for Sunburn